Loling at the people putting AdP and Kewell in. They haven't done nearly enough to be in the A-League Best XI.

Love the troll attempt, but Ljubo was actually a beast in the HAL, whilst Velaphi earned a socceroos call up :lol:
I think Emerton deserves a spot in that side

any side would have to include muscat, thompson & carlos

Tando Velaphi

Steve McMahon Jnr - Bob Malcolm - Ljubo Milicevic - Jeremy Christie

Ahmed Elrich - Kaz Patafta - Leandro Love - Yuning Zhang

Mario Jardel - Dexter Rosales (c)

Manager: Steve MacMahon

carlos hernandez

-----------------------------Bosnich---------------------------

Emerton--------Muscat----------Popovic-------Vidmar

-------------------------------Grella--------------------------

Juninho------------------York------------------Del Piero

------------------Fowler-------------Romario-------------

Galekovic

Traore - Zmonster - Moore - Cassio

Milligan - McKay

Hernandez - ADP - Broich

Thompson

Subs: Theo, Yorke, Og, Carle, Smeltz


Edited by .:bp:.: 12/7/2013 11:38:09 PM

Reserves: Galekovic, Gumprecht, Wilkinson, Smeltz, Dodd

Edited by chillbilly: 12/7/2013 11:09:49 PM

Galekovic
Alagich- Ognenovski- Zwaanswijk-Cassio
Muscunt
Hernandez-AdP
Kruse - Thompson - Broich

I'm shocked at the lack of love for Muscat in these lists, the best captain in the short history of the HAL and easily amongst the best defenders to grace the league.

Haha, I swear I had him in my XI ](*,)

I'm far from a Victory fan but I can't beleive how anyone has made a list that doesn't have Muscat and Thompson in it. Short memories.

No Archie at all? Tsk tsk.

BENCH: Theo, Archie, Muscat, Broich, Oar.

(Smeltz, Kewell, Fred, Carlos, J.Griff, Rogic, Ono, Traore, Wilkinson, McKay, J.Burns, Paartalu, Carle) - Would be in contention.

Imagine if the AllStars was made up from the current HAL players on my list!

Edited by Roarz: 12/7/2013 07:06:04 PM

Bojic may well get a run in both :lol:

Not sure why Broich is selected as a CAM? He's never really played there for Roar....everyone thinks he is one but he actually plays as a LW. Maybe Roar fans can clarify, but I don't think i've ever seen him (start) a game in that position.
So Hernandez surely has a rightful claim to that position.

Screw the best XI. Someone do a WORST XI. The likes of Malcolm, etc.

Romario :lol:

GK Bosnich
Def Moore
Def Neil
Def Zwaansik
RM Juninho
LM Kewell
CM Ono
CM Del Pierro
CF Heskey
CF Romario
CF Yorke

Res Culina
Res Fowler
Res Covic

GK - Galekovic
RB - Franjic
LB - Cassio
CB - Ognenovski and Zwanswijk
DM - Talay
AM - Carle
RW - Thompson
LW - Broich
Str - Del Piero, Smeltz

Edited by thupercoach: 12/7/2013 06:40:24 AM

Stopped reading at Pedj...

------------Galekovic-------------
Bojic--Ogmosnter--Muscat--Cassio
-----------------Milligan-----------------
--Kruse-------Broich--------Thompson
----------Smeltz---------ADP-------------




Edited by parle_ku: 11/7/2013 05:32:46 PM

Muscat - OG. And why the fuck does traore have to win a championship to be considered a top player? Steve Gerrard hasn't won the PL ever but is still one of the greatest english midfielders ever. Our football media has such an AFL mentality......

---------------Eugene---------------
North-----Thwaite----Moore----Cassio
---------Milligan--T.Brown----------
------------Hernandez---------------
J.Griffiths---Smeltz------A.Thompson

Not a terrible list but alot of things I'd do differently.

Only judging on the past 3 seasons (since I've been properly into our league) I'd feel comfortable saying Milligan, McKay, Kruse, Thompson and Broich all probably deserve their spots.

fun fact: whenever making a top 10/greatest ever list, never actually make an attempt at a legitimate list. your exclusions create discussion, which creates hits, which creates ad revenue for soulless snake oil salesmen.

This is pretty damn good.
Carney is unlucky to miss out, but this side is pretty spot on.

Heck I'm bored, this my tip for Perth's A-League XI:

----------------Vukovic
Risdon----Todd--Thwaite----Lazaridis
------------Burns-----Amaral
Ward----------Miller----------Rukavysta
-----------------Fowler

Subs:
Velaphi
Colosimo
Harnwell
Despotovski
Dadi
Sterjovski

Edited by Eastern Glory: 11/7/2013 03:46:48 PM

Hernandez/Broich is either way really.

Cassio not there is a joke. I can understand picking Theo but yeah that whole Bojic and SFC line was cringeworthy.

Not sure who should be at RB, probably Franjic, but wouldn't select Muscut or Bogic there.