Knees like that should be a long suspension... real dog shot. 

How the f#ck did the Eels player not get sent to the bin for the shoulder charge on Tedesco?

HD.... the concerning thing with that incident was what was J Moz doing to the injured player?

I don't think Jmoz passed his medical degree, but he did study with the legendary Dr Marki.

I think that the Roosters may fire up and win this.

I've still got it.

So you wanna be a champion?

You have three gift?

The gift?

Yep, if you need a holday from mocking,I can step in 
#Apprentice

But, was it deliberate? Plenty of times players slide into tackles. I rarely think they deliberately attack the player with their knees. How else do you slide into a player. 

The point is it's  illegal and dangerous and the number of "accidents" will increase if ignored. 

This looks more deliberate than I have seen for a while.

Often the player does slip or slide, seems to me Brown was in control and dropped the knee.

We see what the judiciary makes of it, might not be as bad as I think.

The problem is that Rugby League is a collision sport and it is inevitable that players will be injured. I do not for one instance believe that any player will deliberately intend to cause injury to another.

Pretty naive thought

So you think they go out to deliberately kill, mame and injure. I think it's naive to believe that thuggery still openly exists in the modern game.

Being a collision sport it only takes a careless placement of an elbow, forearm or shoulder for a tackle to go from "good" to "dangerous".

100% agree.
It's called bracing for impact.

When the plane is about to go down and the pilot says Brace! Brace! Brace!, they dont expect you to wrap your arms around the seat in front of you to protect the seat.... they expect you to wrap your hands on your chest or tuck your knees up and bury your head in them to "cushion" the impact.

Some cynics believe it is done to endure you break your neck easier and have a quicker and less painful death.

Injure means to hurt or cause harm to. You don't  think that any player intends to do This?

Well I just saw a replay of the Brown incident as I hadn't seen the game.

Yep. He's in trouble. No need to make that play. He was never going to stop the tryscorer and he himself was never in danger. He stupidly went on with the decision to collide with the try scorer and he shoukd be punished for it.

I was under the impression from reading the posts on here that it was more of a 50-50 play at making the tackle and he then braced once he realised he couldnt, but he was no where stopping the try and should never had led with a knee slide.

I think you’re confusing hurt with injure.

Every one of them wants to hurt. Not many, if any, mean to injure.

There’s a certain brotherhood in sport, especially at the highest levels where they know each other personally.

And yeah I know you’ll pick out the odd crackpot, and I can name one from the past - Ron Gibbs, but they’re very much the minority. Almost on their own. And all despised by their peers.

But Dylan Brown’s not one of them. He just f***ed up.

Mdog if any player takes the field and makes a conscious decision to eliminate another player from the game it is nothing short of thuggery and needs to be stamped out of the game.

We can only judge each incident on what we see.

Reckless is almost as bad as deliberate.

What I didn't like was Brown made no attempt at avoiding the collision that I could see.

For example trying to jump over the player, change direction, or slow down.

The play was over, it was either a try or no try, contact wss totally unnecessary and reckless.

And hd if it was deliberate then he should be given a lengthy stint on the sideline.

I just read the report about the referees. They have been absolute sh!t all year and nothing has been done to rectify the incompetence, yet Trent Robinson has a b!tch and all of a sudden, bingo, they have been stood down. Talk about double standards.

Where are you dman ? 

I don’t disagree 

It is hard to tell the difference between reckless and deliberate.

I've watched a lot of footy over the years. My opinion was reckless or deliberate, also very dangerous.
I want a lengthy stint.
High shots or shoulder charges when a player is stepping, changing direction, dropping or the defender gets the timing wrong, clumsy or careless, reckless is next step up IMO.

I don't know what Brown is like, maybe it is a brain snap, or just a lack of care and focus, is it hard to say.
But going by the vision it should be 4 weeks minimum IMO.

Ring around all the pubs in Sydney, start in the shire... they will know him.