its a fairly mixed bag and u could argue either way, but state league clubs do produce a lot of good talent. in saying that there are many ex-A-League players to go on in Europe, with mixed results in terms of success.
But u mentioned Carle, Carney,Leijer, D.Williams + Vidosic (current Socceroo), Djite (Socceroo), Jedinak (Socceroo), Rukavytsya, Nathan Burns, James holland, zadkovich, bozanic, susak.
plenty who've avoided the A-League have come back. ie.Jamieson, Giraldi, Rostyn Griffiths, shane huke, patafta, andrija jukic,dilevski

Didnt know that.. thanks for the info.

If memory serves me correctly Rhys Williams left here at a very young age to go to UK, hence not getting a chance to play for perth glory in the nsl, Let me guess before the socceroos game recently you had no idea who he was, Spiro's strugging for game time, so is fed,(though it might change next season, fingers crossed) Avraam never heard of him and im positive im not alone in that department, nuff said,

Call me whatever you like for me voicing my opinion on a PUBLIC FORUM douchbag,

Look at some of our most succerful exports from the nsl days - mark viduka, kevin mascot just to name a few, the 4 you named at the bottom are doing better then 5 you named at the top,maybe apart from Leijer but he is at an epl club whereas the rest are lower,

Isnt Avraam Playing for the Greence National Team?

Yeah, think about that.

Adam Federici, Ryan McGowan, Avraam Papadopoulos, Rhys Williams, Matthew Spiranovic... didn't play NSL/A-League, how are they going?

Nick Carle, David Carney, Adrian Leijer, David Williams... ermmm :-k

idiot.

Yer and look where they are now, crawling back to the a-league or bench warming in some out far country with no hope of playing,

I think I saw him on the Australian Football show in a match against South Melbourne. Caught my eye. (well he is black) Very quick, tricky, if that was him.

yeah I have seen him - extremely impressive - he will be overseas soon - rumours are holland - Heidelberg have had a couple of A-League clubs approach them and told them they are not interested and to shove their 3 Grand up their arse

And besides - how many players have made it overseas from the A-League? - more have actually gone overseas from grass roots directly

He has previously trialed at sydney fc before i believe

Yes, Indeed, He Accually Was Wearing the Number 10 Shirt.

In the Second Game Against Melbourne Victory, The 3-1 Win He Scored 1 Goal With Green Gully Player Grabbing a Brace.

His Definitly Reckonized By VPL as a Valuable Player.

Nice find - Anyone else seen him in action? Was he picked for the recent VPL All-Stars games against Victory?

Osagie Ederaro Is Currently Playing in the Victorian Premier League for Heidelberg United.

On Channel 31, They Have the Wrap Ups Weekly, Ive Seen a Few of Heidelberg's Games, This Player Osagie Ederaro Is a Brilliant Talent and Is Ready for the Next Level.

Osagie Ederaro Is Fast and Has a Very Powerful Shot and Can Play on Right Midfield/Wing or In Attack. In 10 Matches His Scored 10 Goals, Thats Almost Half of Heidelberg's Goals. His Brilliant Skill and Fast Pace Is Always Helful. He Could Be In the A-League Very Soon.

Lots of Notable Players Have Come From the Heidelberg Warriors, This Being:
* Kevin Muscat (Yeah Yeah, I Know Non-Melbourne Supporters Hate Him But His a Great Footballer.)
* Bobby Despotovski (Perth Glory Legend)
* Gary Cole (Appeared 40 Times for the Socceroos Scoring 20 Goals.)
* Lawrie McKinna (Current Central Coast Mariners Boss.)

This Could Be the Next Star.
Maybe Fury Can Snap Up this One. Even for a Team to Put Him In the Youth League.