Ok this debate has been going on for way to long and its getting tiresome.
but i am interested in how many people favour one over the other.
I'll be supporting our team with all my heart regardless of who plays and i'm proud of both players even with their obvious weaknesses.

There are debates like this about team selections going on all over the world so don't feel upset that supporters are criticising individual players.
I think it's healthy for a growing football nation.

I pick Carle.

I definitely hate you for this poll.

I'm a Holman fan, and regardless of the result of this poll, I win. :lol:

Team Carle

Carle fan

In terms of future potential, hard work and club achievements; Holman is the superior player.

:lol:

Yep, seconded. Holman fans have already won the war. :cool:

Interesting start.
cmon Carle fans where are you.

Turd Burglar.

This Poll should be all the information need regarding Holminho. [size=2]Vote if you haven't already[/size] :p

Carle wastes his time ploughing away in the Championship in struggling teams...when he isn't on the bench. Holman plays in a successful side in the top flight in Holland.

Seriously if you were Pim who would you pick? And the real question is wtf has Carle been thinking?