This thread is a prime example of one of the very few things that shit me about this forum. Posters go to the effort to start an interesting thread or in this case spend time creating something interesting to share only to be slammed by a handful of knuckle draggers for daring to have different tastes to themselves. Seriously ](*,) ](*,)

Yeah edit the colours and it would look like a good crest for a jersey like the Roma one. It would need tweeking for the full crest but that can easily be done. Good work.

Sydney FC is an interesting one. Never thought they would need to change theirs but really the text outside of the shield is annoying. it can be improved on. I saw a few Sydney FC fans would like an nautical theme to their crest.

I see no real improvements in the 5 logos he did. Most of them are meh. CCM one looks like some dodgy seafood restaurant in Batemans Bay.
The Perth one looks terrible, the MV and Adelaide he shouldn't have even bothered,and there is no improvement at all on the Jets one.

Brisbane is probably the only team in the HAL that really needs a new logo. The others are passable.

Never thought you were.

And btw, I think you've made it pretty clear what you think of the logo - no need to labour it.

Not questioning the success of the club at all, just a shame they've done it with such a shit logo.

Couldn't disagree more.
Roar are the club most desperately in need of a re-fresh IMO.

Please state the part of my post where I criticized the design choice.

Victory- It's ok a bit darker but I think this is an crest that should never be touched. It's a very good one.

Mariners- Nice, I don't like the waves. It reminds me off the Newcastle Breakers. Pretty sure the Mariners also used a darker yellow/gold one year so the darker shade is fitting.

Adelaide- I wouldn't say it's bad but surely there could be some other interesting ideas out there? I'm not a fan of something going outside the crest. In this case, the three lines.

Perth- Nice idea but the 'soccer' ball is always something I don't like to see on football crest and that's why the Mariners one looks so much better. The football looks like a weapon with all those spikes. Change the ball to a black swan and then it'd look much better I think. Ok, it'll look a bit like Swansea but why not?

Newcastle- I really like the non curved crest. Well done.

I think Sydney could see some interesting designs.

Central coast, jets and Melbourne ones are great and would be happy to see the logos change to those ones. I'd love to see us change our crest. Have you done any sydney ones.

3 Championships and 2 Premierships.

I'd hazard a guess its not just me who thinks so :lol:

It's funny because only you seem to think so.

I like the CC one.

Good job.

Edited by iridium1010: 27/7/2014 05:07:56 PM

Adelaide need a new crest entirely.

The Perth one makes absolutely no sense.

I like the Mariners one. The other ones are just basically the same with a darker tone.

We seem to have done alright with it ;)

Hate the AU redesign. Our current badge is perfect to me. Nothing is more plastic than changing club crests after 10 years of existence.

That said, something needs to be done with the horrific current Brisbane logo.

What's the obsession with making colours darker?

This is Australia. It's bright and sunny here. I don't think darker automatically = better.

Awesome job. I love the Jets and Mariners logos in particular. Never really liked the Victory 'Arsenal Rip Off' crest, not sure how we could fix it but to me it looks like it has been thrown together in 5 mins.

Michael Taylor Design launched a new project this year ( 2015 ) to re-design the A-League and then create a new tiered football system with a second division, the plan for a third division lost pace. In addition, he has added expansion teams to the A-league as requested by "Expand the A-League" Facebook page.

This is the completed project:





Existing teams:

Central Coast Mariners


Melbourne Victory


Newcastle United Jets


Brisbane Roar


Adelaide United


Melbourne City


Perth Glory


Western Sydney Wanderers


Wellington Phoenix


Sydney FC


New teams:

Canberra United


Auckland City


AFC Geelong


North Queensland Fury








Tasmania United


Cairns Flying Foxes ( Was originally going to be Cairns Taipans but changed once designer was aware of the basketball team by the same name )



Sporting Fremantle


Darwin FC


Ipswich Dons


Christchurch Saints


Gold Coast United


Brisbane Strikers


Sunshine Coast Heat FC


Ballarat Red Devils


Adelaide City


Wollongong Wolves


South Melbourne


Sydney Olympic FC


Domestic Cups



"So this was included in the first post, and some of you really wanted to know about the domestic cups. The top two are the leagues. The Westfield FFA Cup currently exists, and is between all the teams in the A-League and the teams that qualify from the regional leagues. The Kiwi Cup would be a round robin between the 3 New Zealand teams.

But the State Cup is new. I had this idea very early on. The premise would be an 8 team tournament featuring one from each state and territory. The teams would qualify in their own state before the final tournament."



"Here's a breakdown of teams from the two leagues I made. Clearly the top 3 have a tougher time, but it would even out with expanded qualification from lower leagues. Just something I had an idea for, and thought I should share for the finale."

---

ORIGINAL POST

So following on from the continued interest in the Brisbane Roar crest I thought it might be a nice idea to open a thread that covers more generally the A-League as a whole. So please post any opinions, banter and design ideas for any of the A-league clubs.

One set of redesigns that cought my eye was by Michael Taylor Design ( http://sportslogospot.blogspot.com.au/2013_04_01_archive.html ) before the start of last season ( 2013 ).

He only completed 5 teams and I have asked him if any more are on the way but alas the project is on the backburner.

My personal favs out of what he did would be Central Coast Mariners and Perth Glory.

But the Adelaide United crest I think has too much white, I think the 'United' needs to be larger and put the FC down into the white space. I think it would use the space better and poroduce a better crest overal.

Have a look and tell me what you guys think.

Perth Glory:

"The second team in my series is Perth. Their logo is pretty gradient-astic. There isn’t really imagery for glory, so I took the sun burst and ball and just kinda created around it. I did a vertical oval, took some creative liberties, added the name and year, and thought the final product was pretty good."

Melbourne Victory:

"I feel like the Victory are a few minor tweaks away from a great crest. I cut down on the amount of grey used around the V shape. I took the outlines around the Victory, really just tried to make the whole look fresher."

Central Coast Mariners:

"My 3rd A-League rebrand, this time the newly crowned champions. I wanted to put the logo entirely into a circle, so I ended up with a yellow and navy circle. I used powder blue as another color in addition to the main two. Instead of the wave, I put an anchor."

Newcastle United Jets:

"The crest was a difficult upgrade, because the colors don't work together on how I normally go about logos, with the darker colors always making outlines. I did what I could, and just tried to clean up the look.I adjusted all the colors a little to try and make them pop."

Adelaide United:

"So this was the first team I did in this series. The logo had a lot of potential, but it needed to not look thrown together. I made the blue bolder, thickened the outlines, and arched the words to make it look like it isn’t slapped on there."


Edited by Volrath2002: 27/7/2014 05:43:50 PM

Edited by volrath2002: 9/7/2015 01:59:42 PM