Beauchamp probably there cause hes got height and german experience but doubt he'll play.

Guest
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t1mvlNK3aG8&feature=player_embedded

Edited by russjb: 11/5/2010 12:00:36 PM

TOMMY OAR!!! lowry is no good, rather take colos, og or spira.

I challenge anyone to give me a solid argument as to why Carle should go ahead of Holman.

None of this Carle has flair, Holman has a horrible touch shit I want real evidence proving Carle is better than Holman.

@ Stifle'rs mum. Michael Beachamp WTF? x 1 million.

Pim's decision to shore up the central defense, over Ognenovski. FARRRK

The guy is a disaster waiting to happen. If he takes the filed as a centreback we are screwed.

Of those I think Vidosic should be a certainty, and it would be a tricky decision between Carle and Oar. Totally different players really.

^Holman and Vidosic will be preferred i think.

Edited for accuracy.

Glad he wasnt picked.... He has been great for the game and the socceroos in the past. However no one can say over the last year he has played well enough to be on the plane...

31 including galekovic means 8 cuts to be made.. Hmm my breakdown of it:

Galekovic, lowry, holland, Garcia are fairly certain to be cut you'd think.

Which leaves beauchamp and north to battle for final defence position (both trash I'd prefer sasa or even spira but oh well). On that would probably give to north due to playing at higher level/more versatile.

Also, one of jedinak or valeri will surely be cut due to our amount of DM's. I'd personally prefer jedinak.

Leaving carle, holman, vidosic and oar battling for final 2 midfield spots.hmm I've got no idea on that one what you guys rekon?

They all deserve their chance.

Don't forget, most of these guys are the ones that got them there. All of the nations in the world use this as a selection criteria.

Holman!!!!!!! Leave him off the plane please

A pity, eh? He was always a solid Socceroo, but Dave Mitchell killed his chances. :cry:

no Killkenny?

Michael Beachamp WTF?

"Kemp"

LOL Kemp gets considered and one of our most in form players atm, Joel Griffiths does not? Not saying either should go I just think its a bit fascicle Kemp was even in the picture.

lets face it, he had a shit season and hasnt made any impressions.

and he considered steffanuto

get over it Robbie Slater. pim has always said that the a-league was never up to that standard, so dont bitch about a-league players not getting picked.

Will he also take some development players like how Guus took three?? Or is that holland??

No Sterjovski.

Carle, Moore, Beauchamp and he considered Kemp..... he is on the fucking wacky tobacy.

Jesse Fink will be a happy man. At least for a week or two.

No colosimo. I though he would have at least made an extended 30 man squad

Frickin hell, go away Carle.

Garcia was a surprise inclusion for me

How many A-League players, past or present?

Hmm thanks, so the 8 culls for final 23 I'd expect:

Carle
Beauchamp
Vidosic
Lowry
Holland
Garcia
Galekovic
North

Although personally I really hope Carle goes over he who shall not be named :P
And I prefer Galekovic went too.

i think its a good squad and hopefully all the lads can stay fit and give pim headaches on june 1.

vidosic
wilkshire