|
Mick O
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 1.8K,
Visits: 0
|
I doubt Sezer was ever a chance to come back. I heard there was a major falling out between him and a lot at the club including Grub.
And let’s wait a few more games before we hail him King. It’s only early in the year.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Mick O
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 1.8K,
Visits: 0
|
+xIt is slightly harder starting but the stat's show Salmon is not as good as Mann and Curran. Curran zero errors in 4 games the other guys 2 errors in 4 games which is too many. I didn't list penalties but that stat also isn't good for Salmon. The stat's back up what my eyes are seeing the other 2 guys are better players than Salmon. He isn't a starting lock, he isn't in my top 17, one or 2 injuries and he is definitely in the 17. Most of his NRL career to date has been like that. Those stats really show how poor Salmon has been. I even dug a little deeper. Salmon isn’t engaging the line or pushing players into line breaks. Maybe there is something more the stats don’t show. Maybe Salmon gets the ball to Hutch or Burton quicker than the others. I highly doubt that though. Defensively he looks poor as well. Maybe he is doing the extras that aren’t shown in the stats. But I find it hard to back him now. Although it will be interesting to see his stats at seasons end.
You definitely convinced me on Salmon for now. Curran to lock and Mann bench lock. Salmon utility.
|
|
|
|
|
dman2018
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 8.7K,
Visits: 0
|
+x+x+x+xMuch like Rd 1-20 last year and all.the year before, our opponents know they only need to focus pressure on our left side attack... On the right just number up... Our trys this season have been fairly evenly split between left and right. But we've utterly bombed more on the right... Been unlucky not get more on the left .. And easier to score on the left cos D is focused on the right... We score more tries on the left with a decent 7 controlling the right and middle... Not controlling as such, but attracting more attention...
|
|
|
|
|
dman2018
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 8.7K,
Visits: 0
|
+x+x+xMuch like Rd 1-20 last year and all.the year before, our opponents know they only need to focus pressure on our left side attack... On the right just number up... Our trys this season have been fairly evenly split between left and right. But we've utterly bombed more on the right... Been unlucky not get more on the left .. And easier to score on the left cos D is focused on the right... We score more tries on the left with a decent 7 controlling the right and middle...
|
|
|
|
|
dman2018
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 8.7K,
Visits: 0
|
+x+x+xSezer very good for the Tigers, not surprised I wanted to sign him. I was disappointed when he left the Dogs, not as disappointed as when we let Thurston go. Also disappointed with the retirement and loss of f9rm from Sherwin. All up 3 big reasons why we haven't had a top quality half for a while. All decisions made around the same time. Yep... He has those 1 or 2 very good games a year... His general play kicking after they got back in front was very poor... I've only seen the highlights... IMO Sezer has the ability to be a top half and his is a naturally skilled kicker.. Dogs needed to do a better job of developing him. At the time his manager didn't help matters, There was some breakdown of communication. At Canberra Sticky was a tough task master. Woulda coulda etc... There's a reason he went to England... And a reason the tigers were the only interested party for realistically one year ... I will say he's good at kicking a field goal ..
|
|
|
|
|
dman2018
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 8.7K,
Visits: 0
|
+x+xMuch like Rd 1-20 last year and all.the year before, our opponents know they only need to focus pressure on our left side attack... On the right just number up... Our trys this season have been fairly evenly split between left and right. But we've utterly bombed more on the right... Been unlucky not get more on the left ..
|
|
|
|
|
hounddog
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 9.9K,
Visits: 0
|
+xMuch like Rd 1-20 last year and all.the year before, our opponents know they only need to focus pressure on our left side attack... On the right just number up... Our trys this season have been fairly evenly split between left and right.
|
|
|
|
|
hounddog
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 9.9K,
Visits: 0
|
+x+xSezer very good for the Tigers, not surprised I wanted to sign him. I was disappointed when he left the Dogs, not as disappointed as when we let Thurston go. Also disappointed with the retirement and loss of f9rm from Sherwin. All up 3 big reasons why we haven't had a top quality half for a while. All decisions made around the same time. Yep... He has those 1 or 2 very good games a year... His general play kicking after they got back in front was very poor... I've only seen the highlights... IMO Sezer has the ability to be a top half and his is a naturally skilled kicker.. Dogs needed to do a better job of developing him. At the time his manager didn't help matters, There was some breakdown of communication. At Canberra Sticky was a tough task master.
|
|
|
|
|
dman2018
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 8.7K,
Visits: 0
|
Much like Rd 1-20 last year and all.the year before, our opponents know they only need to focus pressure on our left side attack... On the right just number up...
|
|
|
|
|
dman2018
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 8.7K,
Visits: 0
|
+xSezer very good for the Tigers, not surprised I wanted to sign him. I was disappointed when he left the Dogs, not as disappointed as when we let Thurston go. Also disappointed with the retirement and loss of f9rm from Sherwin. All up 3 big reasons why we haven't had a top quality half for a while. All decisions made around the same time. Yep... He has those 1 or 2 very good games a year... His general play kicking after they got back in front was very poor...
|
|
|
|
|
dman2018
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 8.7K,
Visits: 0
|
+xI like that Ciro is creating a good defensive outfit. Changes will hurt that so moving players around is a terrible idea.
Salmon is fantastic defensively and feeds the ball well to the halves. He has to start at 13. Curran and Mann give us that point of difference. Best staying off the bench Changes this week are difficult with as many changes required by injury... Salmon doesn't run the ball anywhere near enough when in the forwards, and has little impact when he does...
|
|
|
|
|
Marki
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 6.7K,
Visits: 0
|
+xSezer very good for the Tigers, not surprised I wanted to sign him. I was disappointed when he left the Dogs, not as disappointed as when we let Thurston go. Also disappointed with the retirement and loss of f9rm from Sherwin. All up 3 big reasons why we haven't had a top quality half for a while. All decisions made around the same time. Yeah like you, i also was disappointed losing Sezer originally and then not going after him before his move to the Raiders and even last year when we both mentioned it. Especially since we are warming up the spot for our younger guys to come through. I still think Hutch can do this role but i think Sezer has proven he can do it and at a better level.
|
|
|
|
|
hounddog
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 9.9K,
Visits: 0
|
It is slightly harder starting but the stat's show Salmon is not as good as Mann and Curran.
Curran zero errors in 4 games the other guys 2 errors in 4 games which is too many.
I didn't list penalties but that stat also isn't good for Salmon.
The stat's back up what my eyes are seeing the other 2 guys are better players than Salmon.
He isn't a starting lock, he isn't in my top 17, one or 2 injuries and he is definitely in the 17. Most of his NRL career to date has been like that.
|
|
|
|
|
hounddog
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 9.9K,
Visits: 0
|
Stat's.
Week 1 meters tackles missed/t errors
Salmon 41 35 2 1
Mann 113 35 0 0
Curran 97 39 3 0
Week 2
Salmon 55 26 0 0
Mann 73 35 1 0
Curran 95 40 2 0
Week 3
Salmon 81 27 1 0
Mann 96 35 2 1
Curran 126 30 1 0
Week 4
Salmon 72 31 6 1
Mann 107 27 0 1
Curran 136 29 1 0
|
|
|
|
|
hounddog
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 9.9K,
Visits: 0
|
Injuries and suspensions force our hand this week, we need to replace Fox, Morrin and Preston.
Wilson for Fox is the easy change.
IMO Curran has done enough to earn a starting spot.
|
|
|
|
|
hounddog
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 9.9K,
Visits: 0
|
Sezer very good for the Tigers, not surprised I wanted to sign him. I was disappointed when he left the Dogs, not as disappointed as when we let Thurston go. Also disappointed with the retirement and loss of f9rm from Sherwin.
All up 3 big reasons why we haven't had a top quality half for a while. All decisions made around the same time.
|
|
|
|
|
Mick O
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 1.8K,
Visits: 0
|
+x+xThe game is to be better defensively. We are doing that. As Ciro said in the press conference. We let in two easy try’s. Stop those and we win easy.
That’s the main reason why I can’t imagine any changes. Wilson for fox. KK for Presto. Farmer for Morrin. Like for like snd obviously can play to the defensive structure Ciro wants. This makes sense. That’s what I think will happen. And I understand why. I don’t agree with the team that started the season. But it’s predictable what Cirro will do.
My team personally.
Fullback Critta
Wingers Fox and Kiraz
Centres Tracey and Xeri
Halves Burton and Sexton
Props Knight and King with Farmer and Hughes bench
Edge forwards Kiks and Presto
Locks Salmon and Curran bench
Utility Mann and Hutchinson.
|
|
|
|
|
Marki
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 6.7K,
Visits: 0
|
+xThe game is to be better defensively. We are doing that. As Ciro said in the press conference. We let in two easy try’s. Stop those and we win easy.
That’s the main reason why I can’t imagine any changes. Wilson for fox. KK for Presto. Farmer for Morrin. Like for like snd obviously can play to the defensive structure Ciro wants. This makes sense.
|
|
|
|
|
Mick O
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 1.8K,
Visits: 0
|
I like that Ciro is creating a good defensive outfit. Changes will hurt that so moving players around is a terrible idea.
Salmon is fantastic defensively and feeds the ball well to the halves. He has to start at 13. Curran and Mann give us that point of difference. Best staying off the bench
|
|
|
|
|
Mick O
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 1.8K,
Visits: 0
|
The game is to be better defensively. We are doing that. As Ciro said in the press conference. We let in two easy try’s. Stop those and we win easy.
That’s the main reason why I can’t imagine any changes. Wilson for fox. KK for Presto. Farmer for Morrin. Like for like snd obviously can play to the defensive structure Ciro wants.
|
|
|
|
|
Marki
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 6.7K,
Visits: 0
|
+x+x+x+x+x+xSome players out of the Chooks clash. Foxy - concussion- 1-2 weeks. Morrin- suspended- 2 weeks. Preston- fractured jaw - 3-4 weeks. We are forced to make changes and cover Preston longer term. Wilson for Foxy is the easy change. IMO Farmer starting and Knight back to the bench. I would move Salmon to right edge backrower and start Curran. If we are going to gamble on Sexton, Salmon will help him, we don't want Sexton teamed up with a rookie backrower. We need to find one more high workrate player for the bench who can also cover backrow, if KK is available he would be first choice followed by Edwards. The left field suggestion would be Xerri gambling on him or Kiraz filling in in the forwards if necessary. Bloody terrible news re Presto... The Fish to edge makes sense... It makes even more sense if long term plan is Curran to 13... I do not like these left wing ideas of playing guys like Kiraz out of position... He's way too valuable at centre or wing... Fair point, the problem I have is the lack of cover in the outside backs or spine with injury/HIA. We where pretty unlucky both times Fox got injured and it definitely cost us. There are 4 spine players + 4 outside backs who can potentially get injuries/HIA and 5 forwards on the field + at least 3 on the bench. Forwards are more likely to get involved in big collisions. Making it even trickier for us, Farmer, Hughes and Knight can't play big minutes. We have a good young player Samarini who looks like an ideal guy to cover backrow and centre off the bench, but he is a bit too young / inexperienced to pick at this stage. Lachlan Vale racked up 45 tackles playing second row in reserve grade, don't know much about him. Against the Chooks we definitely need Farmer, Knight and Hughes, but we also need fit high workrate players to cancel that out. Our forwards don't have the minutes to carry a specialist back on the bench, injury / HIA is then a big risk. Next time we will need to try Mann in the centres, that may work better than Salmon... While I don't rate Salmon's running or passing in the middle or centre, I think it might work out in the backrow. If he is hitting a hole he doesn't necessarily need footwork and he runs hard enough. Passing to his centre partner or dropping the centre under suits his passing. Even a pass to the winger is within his range. If we keep him at lock we might play Curran on the edge. I would not do that but Cirro might. Mann should have gone to centre both times... I tend to agree with this. Mann does alot of jinking (sometimes too much). He wouldn't look out of sorts in the centres and probably should have the first optiom to play there while we had injuries and HIAs. He needs to cut oit some of that jinking coz at times he looks like he jinks back towards the player he just beat. Mann is a good player in attack and defence. Our problem is guys trying to solve the problem in attack by themselves and doing too much. No problem with Mann at first receiver he throws a good long pass, but if the halves are calling for the ball he should pass it to them. If the halves are not set up for a play then ad lib. I want to see what the team can achieve if we become well organised and work together, taking more good options. Get the ball to Kiks and Taaffe at the right times, we should be able score enough points. Not sure that the guys can get our act together, as per the defence, we need a style and an identity. . A bit of jinking can draw defenders to Mann providing the opportunity to pass to a guy in space. Taaffe and some of our backs should be running off him. Fast guys through a gap in the middle. If he simply jinks at slow speed and no one makes a run it will not do much. I have noticed Taaffe positioning himself to run off Hutch once or twice that went close to working. I also don't mind wingers occasionally drifting in field and looking for a gap up the middle. We can't simply be a threat on the edges, down mainstreet is where the big boys are often tired and slow to move. I want to see what Jason Taylor has to offer as an attacking coach, I am hoping he knows what we should be doing. We are definitely better than in previous seasons, but still not at the level id like to see us in attack. I feel as though the ball is not going to our halves sufficiently enough in the attacking zone. I can understand some autopilot play with Mahoney to middle forwards between the 30m zones or inside our 30. But inside the attacking third, we cant afford for Burton and Hutch not calling for the ball and getting their hands on it. Hutch seems to get himself involved more tyan Burton and hence the reason i feel he deserves a halves spot ahead of Burton. But our whole attacking mindset must change in that final third and forwards should be considered as decoys first and support players second. There shouldnt be more than 1 settler run. I do agree that Mann jinking in the middle of the park with support players bursting through can catch some lazy defenders in the middle, and we need to work on this more. We seem to just setup for a left or right sweep play with our fringes as our only attacking hope and when that fails, its the final kick as our crescendo. We need more than that to get to the next level. The eyes of the top halves light up when they get ball inside the opposition 30m. They are disapointed when they dont setup tries before their kicks. We tend to work towards our kick.
|
|
|
|
|
hounddog
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 9.9K,
Visits: 0
|
Sticky sometimes does a very entertaining presser.
I want Canberra to lose for the after match entertainment.
|
|
|
|
|
hounddog
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 9.9K,
Visits: 0
|
+x+x+x+x+xSome players out of the Chooks clash. Foxy - concussion- 1-2 weeks. Morrin- suspended- 2 weeks. Preston- fractured jaw - 3-4 weeks. We are forced to make changes and cover Preston longer term. Wilson for Foxy is the easy change. IMO Farmer starting and Knight back to the bench. I would move Salmon to right edge backrower and start Curran. If we are going to gamble on Sexton, Salmon will help him, we don't want Sexton teamed up with a rookie backrower. We need to find one more high workrate player for the bench who can also cover backrow, if KK is available he would be first choice followed by Edwards. The left field suggestion would be Xerri gambling on him or Kiraz filling in in the forwards if necessary. Bloody terrible news re Presto... The Fish to edge makes sense... It makes even more sense if long term plan is Curran to 13... I do not like these left wing ideas of playing guys like Kiraz out of position... He's way too valuable at centre or wing... Fair point, the problem I have is the lack of cover in the outside backs or spine with injury/HIA. We where pretty unlucky both times Fox got injured and it definitely cost us. There are 4 spine players + 4 outside backs who can potentially get injuries/HIA and 5 forwards on the field + at least 3 on the bench. Forwards are more likely to get involved in big collisions. Making it even trickier for us, Farmer, Hughes and Knight can't play big minutes. We have a good young player Samarini who looks like an ideal guy to cover backrow and centre off the bench, but he is a bit too young / inexperienced to pick at this stage. Lachlan Vale racked up 45 tackles playing second row in reserve grade, don't know much about him. Against the Chooks we definitely need Farmer, Knight and Hughes, but we also need fit high workrate players to cancel that out. Our forwards don't have the minutes to carry a specialist back on the bench, injury / HIA is then a big risk. Next time we will need to try Mann in the centres, that may work better than Salmon... While I don't rate Salmon's running or passing in the middle or centre, I think it might work out in the backrow. If he is hitting a hole he doesn't necessarily need footwork and he runs hard enough. Passing to his centre partner or dropping the centre under suits his passing. Even a pass to the winger is within his range. If we keep him at lock we might play Curran on the edge. I would not do that but Cirro might. Mann should have gone to centre both times... I tend to agree with this. Mann does alot of jinking (sometimes too much). He wouldn't look out of sorts in the centres and probably should have the first optiom to play there while we had injuries and HIAs. He needs to cut oit some of that jinking coz at times he looks like he jinks back towards the player he just beat. Mann is a good player in attack and defence. Our problem is guys trying to solve the problem in attack by themselves and doing too much. No problem with Mann at first receiver he throws a good long pass, but if the halves are calling for the ball he should pass it to them. If the halves are not set up for a play then ad lib. I want to see what the team can achieve if we become well organised and work together, taking more good options. Get the ball to Kiks and Taaffe at the right times, we should be able score enough points. Not sure that the guys can get our act together, as per the defence, we need a style and an identity. . A bit of jinking can draw defenders to Mann providing the opportunity to pass to a guy in space. Taaffe and some of our backs should be running off him. Fast guys through a gap in the middle. If he simply jinks at slow speed and no one makes a run it will not do much. I have noticed Taaffe positioning himself to run off Hutch once or twice that went close to working. I also don't mind wingers occasionally drifting in field and looking for a gap up the middle. We can't simply be a threat on the edges, down mainstreet is where the big boys are often tired and slow to move. I want to see what Jason Taylor has to offer as an attacking coach, I am hoping he knows what we should be doing.
|
|
|
|
|
Marki
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 6.7K,
Visits: 0
|
+x+x+x+xSome players out of the Chooks clash. Foxy - concussion- 1-2 weeks. Morrin- suspended- 2 weeks. Preston- fractured jaw - 3-4 weeks. We are forced to make changes and cover Preston longer term. Wilson for Foxy is the easy change. IMO Farmer starting and Knight back to the bench. I would move Salmon to right edge backrower and start Curran. If we are going to gamble on Sexton, Salmon will help him, we don't want Sexton teamed up with a rookie backrower. We need to find one more high workrate player for the bench who can also cover backrow, if KK is available he would be first choice followed by Edwards. The left field suggestion would be Xerri gambling on him or Kiraz filling in in the forwards if necessary. Bloody terrible news re Presto... The Fish to edge makes sense... It makes even more sense if long term plan is Curran to 13... I do not like these left wing ideas of playing guys like Kiraz out of position... He's way too valuable at centre or wing... Fair point, the problem I have is the lack of cover in the outside backs or spine with injury/HIA. We where pretty unlucky both times Fox got injured and it definitely cost us. There are 4 spine players + 4 outside backs who can potentially get injuries/HIA and 5 forwards on the field + at least 3 on the bench. Forwards are more likely to get involved in big collisions. Making it even trickier for us, Farmer, Hughes and Knight can't play big minutes. We have a good young player Samarini who looks like an ideal guy to cover backrow and centre off the bench, but he is a bit too young / inexperienced to pick at this stage. Lachlan Vale racked up 45 tackles playing second row in reserve grade, don't know much about him. Against the Chooks we definitely need Farmer, Knight and Hughes, but we also need fit high workrate players to cancel that out. Our forwards don't have the minutes to carry a specialist back on the bench, injury / HIA is then a big risk. Next time we will need to try Mann in the centres, that may work better than Salmon... While I don't rate Salmon's running or passing in the middle or centre, I think it might work out in the backrow. If he is hitting a hole he doesn't necessarily need footwork and he runs hard enough. Passing to his centre partner or dropping the centre under suits his passing. Even a pass to the winger is within his range. If we keep him at lock we might play Curran on the edge. I would not do that but Cirro might. Mann should have gone to centre both times... I tend to agree with this. Mann does alot of jinking (sometimes too much). He wouldn't look out of sorts in the centres and probably should have the first optiom to play there while we had injuries and HIAs. He needs to cut oit some of that jinking coz at times he looks like he jinks back towards the player he just beat.
|
|
|
|
|
dman2018
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 8.7K,
Visits: 0
|
+x+x+xSome players out of the Chooks clash. Foxy - concussion- 1-2 weeks. Morrin- suspended- 2 weeks. Preston- fractured jaw - 3-4 weeks. We are forced to make changes and cover Preston longer term. Wilson for Foxy is the easy change. IMO Farmer starting and Knight back to the bench. I would move Salmon to right edge backrower and start Curran. If we are going to gamble on Sexton, Salmon will help him, we don't want Sexton teamed up with a rookie backrower. We need to find one more high workrate player for the bench who can also cover backrow, if KK is available he would be first choice followed by Edwards. The left field suggestion would be Xerri gambling on him or Kiraz filling in in the forwards if necessary. Bloody terrible news re Presto... The Fish to edge makes sense... It makes even more sense if long term plan is Curran to 13... I do not like these left wing ideas of playing guys like Kiraz out of position... He's way too valuable at centre or wing... Fair point, the problem I have is the lack of cover in the outside backs or spine with injury/HIA. We where pretty unlucky both times Fox got injured and it definitely cost us. There are 4 spine players + 4 outside backs who can potentially get injuries/HIA and 5 forwards on the field + at least 3 on the bench. Forwards are more likely to get involved in big collisions. Making it even trickier for us, Farmer, Hughes and Knight can't play big minutes. We have a good young player Samarini who looks like an ideal guy to cover backrow and centre off the bench, but he is a bit too young / inexperienced to pick at this stage. Lachlan Vale racked up 45 tackles playing second row in reserve grade, don't know much about him. Against the Chooks we definitely need Farmer, Knight and Hughes, but we also need fit high workrate players to cancel that out. Our forwards don't have the minutes to carry a specialist back on the bench, injury / HIA is then a big risk. Next time we will need to try Mann in the centres, that may work better than Salmon... While I don't rate Salmon's running or passing in the middle or centre, I think it might work out in the backrow. If he is hitting a hole he doesn't necessarily need footwork and he runs hard enough. Passing to his centre partner or dropping the centre under suits his passing. Even a pass to the winger is within his range. If we keep him at lock we might play Curran on the edge. I would not do that but Cirro might. Mann should have gone to centre both times...
|
|
|
|
|
hounddog
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 9.9K,
Visits: 0
|
If we keep the same side, I would definitely cut down the number of plays where the lock plays first receiver, and/or stand Hutch deeper and move the ball faster.
Marhoney needs to straighten up his game especially in the middle of the field at the opponent's end.
The lock and hooker slowly running across field with a shallow attacking formation gave the opponent's plenty of time to get their line set and move up. Worse still our players tend to get confused as to when to time their runs and often got the ball standing still.
I am sure that the coaches can devise a training drill to sort this out, one that involves a timer and sit ups for punishment. If I was playing that would get me passing fast and running hard, I hate situps.
|
|
|
|
|
hounddog
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 9.9K,
Visits: 0
|
+x+xSome players out of the Chooks clash. Foxy - concussion- 1-2 weeks. Morrin- suspended- 2 weeks. Preston- fractured jaw - 3-4 weeks. We are forced to make changes and cover Preston longer term. Wilson for Foxy is the easy change. IMO Farmer starting and Knight back to the bench. I would move Salmon to right edge backrower and start Curran. If we are going to gamble on Sexton, Salmon will help him, we don't want Sexton teamed up with a rookie backrower. We need to find one more high workrate player for the bench who can also cover backrow, if KK is available he would be first choice followed by Edwards. The left field suggestion would be Xerri gambling on him or Kiraz filling in in the forwards if necessary. Bloody terrible news re Presto... The Fish to edge makes sense... It makes even more sense if long term plan is Curran to 13... I do not like these left wing ideas of playing guys like Kiraz out of position... He's way too valuable at centre or wing... Fair point, the problem I have is the lack of cover in the outside backs or spine with injury/HIA. We where pretty unlucky both times Fox got injured and it definitely cost us. There are 4 spine players + 4 outside backs who can potentially get injuries/HIA and 5 forwards on the field + at least 3 on the bench. Forwards are more likely to get involved in big collisions. Making it even trickier for us, Farmer, Hughes and Knight can't play big minutes. We have a good young player Samarini who looks like an ideal guy to cover backrow and centre off the bench, but he is a bit too young / inexperienced to pick at this stage. Lachlan Vale racked up 45 tackles playing second row in reserve grade, don't know much about him. Against the Chooks we definitely need Farmer, Knight and Hughes, but we also need fit high workrate players to cancel that out. Our forwards don't have the minutes to carry a specialist back on the bench, injury / HIA is then a big risk. Next time we will need to try Mann in the centres, that may work better than Salmon... While I don't rate Salmon's running or passing in the middle or centre, I think it might work out in the backrow. If he is hitting a hole he doesn't necessarily need footwork and he runs hard enough. Passing to his centre partner or dropping the centre under suits his passing. Even a pass to the winger is within his range. If we keep him at lock we might play Curran on the edge. I would not do that but Cirro might.
|
|
|
|
|
dman2018
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 8.7K,
Visits: 0
|
+xSome players out of the Chooks clash. Foxy - concussion- 1-2 weeks. Morrin- suspended- 2 weeks. Preston- fractured jaw - 3-4 weeks. We are forced to make changes and cover Preston longer term. Wilson for Foxy is the easy change. IMO Farmer starting and Knight back to the bench. I would move Salmon to right edge backrower and start Curran. If we are going to gamble on Sexton, Salmon will help him, we don't want Sexton teamed up with a rookie backrower. We need to find one more high workrate player for the bench who can also cover backrow, if KK is available he would be first choice followed by Edwards. The left field suggestion would be Xerri gambling on him or Kiraz filling in in the forwards if necessary. Bloody terrible news re Presto... The Fish to edge makes sense... It makes even more sense if long term plan is Curran to 13... I do not like these left wing ideas of playing guys like Kiraz out of position... He's way too valuable at centre or wing...
|
|
|
|
|
hounddog
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 9.9K,
Visits: 0
|
Some players out of the Chooks clash.
Foxy - concussion- 1-2 weeks.
Morrin- suspended- 2 weeks.
Preston- fractured jaw - 3-4 weeks.
We are forced to make changes and cover Preston longer term.
Wilson for Foxy is the easy change.
IMO Farmer starting and Knight back to the bench.
I would move Salmon to right edge backrower and start Curran.
If we are going to gamble on Sexton, Salmon will help him, we don't want Sexton teamed up with a rookie backrower.
We need to find one more high workrate player for the bench who can also cover backrow, if KK is available he would be first choice followed by Edwards.
The left field suggestion would be Xerri gambling on him or Kiraz filling in in the forwards if necessary.
|
|
|
|
|
hounddog
|
|
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 9.9K,
Visits: 0
|
+x+x+x+x+xNo reason to change the team. We played as well as we could under the conditions. Obviously if we had Cleary, DCE, Reynolds etc we would have taken more opportunities. But we don’t have them. We have an older halfback that has barely played halfback. Sexton might be better but he would change team cohesion. And that could make us even worse.
I’m happy to see no changes. This year we are building a strong defensive team. Next year with better players we can improve I am also happy to see no changes for a week or two or whatever Cirro decides. After the previous game I was ready to drop Taaffe and I thought Hutch and Mann were two of our better players. This week I have completely flipped my ratings. So I think give these players long enough prove if they have it and give the possible next lot plenty of time to prepare. I don't want to see yo-yo selections with guys being dropped and back up two games later. So far I am inclined to agree with Cirro we lost the game due to execution. The first two Souths tries were fairly soft and bad misses by our recent standards. Even that third try we needed more scramble at the start. Foxy being injured wasn't ideal, but the Morrin drop in a try scoring position after doing most of the hard work was a turning point. There are too many times to mention when better execution and decision making from us would have resulted in points. It isn't like the team don't have it in them, they just couldn't get it done. What will it take? It will be a lot easier when we get it done once, Players need to trust the game plan, stick to their role, play to their strengths and execute. And players just need a bit more intent, run harder, stand deeper, move the ball faster. We can't get it done, until we can. Chooks are real contenders and when they get it together very few teams can go with them. So a win against them would be a definite statement, last season we would have waved the white flag before kick-off. What I want to see is intent, us trying to win the game, not just making up the numbers. Win or lose players who stand out in a game like this are quality. When deciding to make team changes all performances this season need to be considered. Anyone we consider for halfback or fullback needs to have played that role in the NRL or reserve grade recently. Rather than actual spine changes I would consider the mix between attack and defence. We need to drop a defensive player and promote an attacking player. Salmon is the guy I would drop based on all games this season. And I would consider trying BBO, Xerri or Skeleton on the bench, what I am after is more leg speed. As soon as we have good cover for Foxy on the bench I bet he finishes every game. What I hate more than anything this season is Salmon moving to the centres after Foxy was injured. I can’t believe we did it twice it doesn't work in attack or defence. I think is needed more than almost anybody else in the team. He is playing that first receiver option well and his defence is very strong. Moving him to the centres was the only real option after the injury. No other player could have done that job as well. Curran, Mann are not centres. And we can’t play a prop there.
As fans unfortunately we just have to accept we don’t have the try scoring ability yet. Not until we find a halfback.
Even Narki hasn’t rubbished Burton after this loss. He was easily our best half. Like I keep saying. He just needs a decent halfback to combine with him. Such a shame about Oloapu. If he didn’t suffer the injury he could have had a whole off season in the halves. I’m assuming he is on the outer now. Similarly if Sexton gets a shot we need his kicking game to at least match Hutch and then he needs to organise the attack. If his running game is better we can allow him a few missed tackles. 7exys kicking game is far superior to Hutchs... And Hutch ain't organising sh1t... Hutch has kicked pretty well the last couple of weeks. I can't remember how Sexty kicked last season. I don't know why Cirro initially preferred Hutch apparently it was a close call. I think we are over compensating for last season so Cirro is favouring good defenders. I don’t think the poor performance against Souths was all on one guy. Marhoney and Mann stuffed a lot of things up and wasted a lot of time before Hutch got the ball... But when we get slow ball to Hutch in space him running is a bad option, that is the sort of thing we need to sort out.
|
|
|
|