A-League Mens - Round 21


A-League Mens - Round 21

Author
Message
LFC.
LFC.
Legend
Legend (13K reputation)Legend (13K reputation)Legend (13K reputation)Legend (13K reputation)Legend (13K reputation)Legend (13K reputation)Legend (13K reputation)Legend (13K reputation)Legend (13K reputation)Legend (13K reputation)Legend (13K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 13K, Visits: 0
it is a small % of the general pop overall to me but 40k get to swans up here to the real G haha you see that.
The other crowd I just checked and as I thought, the other day was a 8k of all places Syd Olympic park that is easy to get to...
Mind you that is kind of AL crowd high.

Alot of freebie ticks are always thrown out my mate tells me but AL does the same.
People like getitng outside, not sure they are all right into afl just that its a day out, bit of a novalty to me.


Love Football

Edited
Last Year by LFC.
Monoethnic Social Club
Monoethnic Social Club
Legend
Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 11K, Visits: 0
robbos - 18 Mar 2024 12:50 PM
Monoethnic Social Club - 18 Mar 2024 10:52 AM

I already answered that question, I used to attend SFC with about 25-30 fans, now its 3-4.
I wrote;
The A-League struggles in Sydney, hardly any talk in pubs, cafes & work places. The Pubs even those near the stadium don't show the A-League.
But stop listening to the Melbourne media, the pubs have the AFL on, hardly anyone watching, go to pubs, cafes or work places & you hardly hear anyone talking AFL.

I don't hate AFL, I just don't care for it, like most people from Sydney. This is what I was telling you when you started posting photos of the Swans & Giants games.
You go to Pubs, cafes, work places, where people get together, if they talking sport they talking NRL, you go the playing fields & mainly kids are either playing football or kicking a round ball around, very rarely do you see those funny posts required for AFL, this is Sydney.

Again mate you are attacking the messenger and NOT the message.. If nobody cares about AFL in Sydney why are there so many people at the AFL matches? (as per images I posted)... 
Edited
Last Year by Monoethnic Social Club
robbos
robbos
Pro
Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 3.8K, Visits: 0
Monoethnic Social Club - 18 Mar 2024 10:52 AM
robbos - 18 Mar 2024 10:15 AM

Melbourne had more Matildas and Australia flags during the WWC than ANYTHING every related to AFL too mate... thats patriotism and womens sport movement, not that hard to understand.

What I was questioning is how popular the Aleague was compared to AFL in Sydney.. Down here in Melbourne it is no competition, just wanted to know if it could possibly be in Sydney... 

I dont hate Rugby mate, just dont understand it nor have ever bothered to. If you hate AFL that is more than fine with me... 

I already answered that question, I used to attend SFC with about 25-30 fans, now its 3-4.
I wrote;
The A-League struggles in Sydney, hardly any talk in pubs, cafes & work places. The Pubs even those near the stadium don't show the A-League.
But stop listening to the Melbourne media, the pubs have the AFL on, hardly anyone watching, go to pubs, cafes or work places & you hardly hear anyone talking AFL.

I don't hate AFL, I just don't care for it, like most people from Sydney. This is what I was telling you when you started posting photos of the Swans & Giants games.
You go to Pubs, cafes, work places, where people get together, if they talking sport they talking NRL, you go the playing fields & mainly kids are either playing football or kicking a round ball around, very rarely do you see those funny posts required for AFL, this is Sydney.
LFC.
LFC.
Legend
Legend (13K reputation)Legend (13K reputation)Legend (13K reputation)Legend (13K reputation)Legend (13K reputation)Legend (13K reputation)Legend (13K reputation)Legend (13K reputation)Legend (13K reputation)Legend (13K reputation)Legend (13K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 13K, Visits: 0
Monoethnic Social Club - 18 Mar 2024 10:52 AM
robbos - 18 Mar 2024 10:15 AM

Melbourne had more Matildas and Australia flags during the WWC than ANYTHING every related to AFL too mate... thats patriotism and womens sport movement, not that hard to understand.

What I was questioning is how popular the Aleague was compared to AFL in Sydney.. Down here in Melbourne it is no competition, just wanted to know if it could possibly be in Sydney... 

I dont hate Rugby mate, just dont understand it nor have ever bothered to. If you hate AFL that is more than fine with me... 

TBH I really can't say that I notice one is more popular than the other (AL/AFL) unless your travelling by near either stadiums or public transport that I don't do that much.
With all the huge dollars afl have spent in our city its a blimp to me whereas I do notice the SFC/WSW shirt wearer heading to games.
I would think swans get more attending games because its a fad and the many melb expats plus swans been aorund since eddelstone days - whatever they are called out west wouldn't have a friggin clue......


Love Football

NicCarBel
NicCarBel
Pro
Pro (3.2K reputation)Pro (3.2K reputation)Pro (3.2K reputation)Pro (3.2K reputation)Pro (3.2K reputation)Pro (3.2K reputation)Pro (3.2K reputation)Pro (3.2K reputation)Pro (3.2K reputation)Pro (3.2K reputation)Pro (3.2K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 3K, Visits: 0
tsf - 18 Mar 2024 10:37 AM
Melbcityguy - 16 Mar 2024 5:30 PM

good. maybe they can f off and start their own league.

It's on FIFA +

Probably as good as NPL lel
Monoethnic Social Club
Monoethnic Social Club
Legend
Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 11K, Visits: 0
Flytox - 15 Mar 2024 10:54 PM
Monoethnic Social Club - 15 Mar 2024 3:59 PM

The new ratings method shows national figures only.  They are not split into the different markets now.  From historical figures maybe 10% would live in Sydney.

Fair enough, but the point still stands that 10% of 2.3 million is alot more than 100% of SFA.
Monoethnic Social Club
Monoethnic Social Club
Legend
Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 11K, Visits: 0
robbos - 18 Mar 2024 10:15 AM
Monoethnic Social Club - 18 Mar 2024 9:59 AM

Yes during Grand final time you see houses & cars with flags of their teams or even during Matildas run in WC.

You are obsessed with your A-League hate. Never did I say A-League bigger than AFL in Sydney, football is yes.
However Sydney is all NRL, with football 2nd (NOT A-League), I know your other pet hate Rugby, but fact AFL is a niche sport in my fair city & hope it remains that way as it's a shit sport.. 

Melbourne had more Matildas and Australia flags during the WWC than ANYTHING every related to AFL too mate... thats patriotism and womens sport movement, not that hard to understand.

What I was questioning is how popular the Aleague was compared to AFL in Sydney.. Down here in Melbourne it is no competition, just wanted to know if it could possibly be in Sydney... 

I dont hate Rugby mate, just dont understand it nor have ever bothered to. If you hate AFL that is more than fine with me... 
tsf
tsf
Legend
Legend (14K reputation)Legend (14K reputation)Legend (14K reputation)Legend (14K reputation)Legend (14K reputation)Legend (14K reputation)Legend (14K reputation)Legend (14K reputation)Legend (14K reputation)Legend (14K reputation)Legend (14K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 14K, Visits: 0
Melbcityguy - 16 Mar 2024 5:30 PM
SUTHERLANDBEAR - 16 Mar 2024 5:16 PM

Scenes if the new Zealand derby overtakes the Australian a league team derbies 

good. maybe they can f off and start their own league.
robbos
robbos
Pro
Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 3.8K, Visits: 0
Monoethnic Social Club - 18 Mar 2024 9:59 AM
SUTHERLANDBEAR - 15 Mar 2024 6:47 PM

Meh, sorry wasnt sure (nor care) if Lowy went full "Sevco" with Hakoa or not.... point still stands, are there many flags hanging outside peoples homes in Sydney?

Yes during Grand final time you see houses & cars with flags of their teams or even during Matildas run in WC.

You are obsessed with your A-League hate. Never did I say A-League bigger than AFL in Sydney, football is yes.
However Sydney is all NRL, with football 2nd (NOT A-League), I know your other pet hate Rugby, but fact AFL is a niche sport in my fair city & hope it remains that way as it's a shit sport.. 
Monoethnic Social Club
Monoethnic Social Club
Legend
Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 11K, Visits: 0
SUTHERLANDBEAR - 15 Mar 2024 8:17 PM
Monoethnic Social Club - 15 Mar 2024 3:33 PM

The top left hand side of the Australian flag suggests that I am in my own country ! Only an observation of course.

Are you talking about the Scottish flag crushed underneath England and Northern Irelands flags?
Monoethnic Social Club
Monoethnic Social Club
Legend
Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)Legend (12K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 11K, Visits: 0
SUTHERLANDBEAR - 15 Mar 2024 6:47 PM
Monoethnic Social Club - 15 Mar 2024 4:33 PM

Sydney city, you say ?  Been gone for a long while at national league level.

Meh, sorry wasnt sure (nor care) if Lowy went full "Sevco" with Hakoa or not.... point still stands, are there many flags hanging outside peoples homes in Sydney?
Roar in me Blood
Roar in me Blood
World Class
World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 4.8K, Visits: 0
Decentric 2 - 17 Mar 2024 11:34 PM
Roar in me Blood - 16 Mar 2024 7:56 PM

Always enjoy your detailed reports. Lucky for you being able to attend live AL football every fortnight in close  proximity! 

Younger players like Jelacic can be prone to inconsistency.

Watching the  game on TV it is interesting to note you thought Mac had better movement when in possession from your live vantage point? Do you think Mac Pressed and Squeezed more effectively than Roar to stifle Roar's passing lanes, hence disturbing Roar build ups more effectively?

Or were  Roar just more static in off the ball movement as they built up?

The latter.

When Macarthur pressed us we played excellent controlled and composed football with our triangles and lateral and backwards passes - but with the purpose and outcome of working through the blockage rather than just being the old 'back and round'. It is a feature of our play that I particularly love to see and we have done it to some of the hardest pressing teams this season.

It is when we are looking to attack and there is a ball carrier and an expected receiver moving and everyone else is standing flat - time and again. You can count on the forwards to take up a line with the opposition centrebacks, the back line to stand in their umbrella back pass stations, one winger to stand flat while the one expecting the ball runs, and the midfield to take up a static position somewhere and wait for a pass. Nobody is putting any pressure on the opposition to move or make decisions that might disrupt them. The issue is that we do not have to play that way - we seemingly fall into that pattern often.

It is actually part of the role of Caletti that I was talking about. He continues to offer options that we may or may not take up all game and they force our opponents to move to cover him. Our wingers are capable of getting in behind and crossing - we see that often - so having a bit more movement in the middle to draw attention away does a lot to help unsettle the defenders when the cross does come in.

When you add in being a goal down, everything about our static build up gives the opposition a much more advantageous position to be playing from when we need them scrambling and making hasty decisions.

When I wear their colours, I am the club.

Decentric 2
Decentric 2
Pro
Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 3.1K, Visits: 0
grazorblade - 17 Mar 2024 7:54 AM
Mark rudan says that he doesnt believe a coach can lose a dressing room

To be fair to him, its something ive heard fans say but has there ever been a confirmed concrete case of that?

Closest i can think of was arnie saying in 07 the players tripped him as a joke in training 

The media are always looking for these sorts of stories.

Not long ago he was doing a good job with a pretty young side. There are unconfirmed reports of players and coaching staff wanting to leave.
Decentric 2
Decentric 2
Pro
Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 3.1K, Visits: 0
someguyjc - 14 Mar 2024 1:25 PM
Thursday 14th March 2024
  • Western United vs Melbourne Victory
    AAMI Park
    Kick-off: 19:00
    Ref: Shane Skinner
    Broadcast: Paramount+
Friday 15th March 2024
  • Newcastle Jets vs Adelaide United
    McDonald Jones Stadium
    Kick-off: 19:45 (Eastcoast time) / 19:15 (SA time)
    Ref: Daniel Elder
    Broadcast: Paramount+
Saturday 16th March 2024
  • Wellington Phoenix vs Sydney FC
    Eden Park, Auckland
    Kick-off: 17:30 (Kiwi time) / 15:30 (Eastcoast time)
    Ref: Alireza Faghani
    Broadcast: Paramount+
  • Brisbane Roar vs Macarthur FC
    Ballymore Stadium
    Kick-off: 15:00 (QLD time) / 16:00 (Eastcoast time)
    Ref: Alex King
    Broadcast: Paramount+
  • Perth Glory vs Western Sydney Wanderers
    HBF Park
    Kick-off: 16:45 (WA time) / 19:45 (Eastcoast time)
    Ref: Shaun Evans
    Broadcast: Paramount+
CURRENT TABLE
(APL RULES)
CURRENT TABLE
(GLOBAL RULES)
ClubPLWDLGDPts*ClubPLGDPts*
CCM2112451640*  CCM211640*
NIX2111731140*  NIX211140*
MV2181031034*MV211034*
MAC21885132*MAC21132*
SFC20947631 SFC20631 
MC21858429*MC21429*
WSW21849-528*WSW21-528*
BR21759-926*BR21-926*
PG20569-421 PG20-421 
AU205411-519 AU20-519 
NJ215411-519*NJ21-519*
WU205312-1618 WU20-1618 
* denotes clubs who have played additional game
For some reason, there are no matches broadcast on FTA TV this weekend.

Again thanks a bunch for posting this and researching it.
Decentric 2
Decentric 2
Pro
Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 3.1K, Visits: 0
sub007 - 16 Mar 2024 10:34 AM
Back to the football...

Last night's game was a pretty ordinary watch and it was clear that both teams have been struggling. Having said that, Adelaide were the better team on the night and really should have won by more. Luka Jovanovic's goal was so well taken and on current form is seriously challenging for an Olyroos spot.

It was a good goal.
Decentric 2
Decentric 2
Pro
Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 3.1K, Visits: 0
Roar in me Blood - 16 Mar 2024 7:56 PM
We got outplayed both individually and as a team.

Macarthur (grubby diving bastards) have better individual skills and today they played better team football too.

Watching them attack, when they chose to, they had 7 players streaming forward when in possession and passed the ball into space to the next running player. When we had the ball we had a ball carrier looking around, everyone standing flat footed in their 'attack positions' and one player who expected the ball up the wing running. We just could not put any consistent pressure on Macarthur's big, strong, skilled defenders the way we were playing.

That said - I remember 4 clear botched attempts at goals that should have all gone in. Two at the feet of our one dedicated striker (Waddingham) who had a shocker in front of goals and skied them both, one was a header directly between me and the goals with no-one in the line of the shot and we headed it wide, and the one miss hit gentle nudge along the ground that rolled towards the open goal and the keeper managed to get to it.

Got to say, scoring first in the opening 20 minutes was a bonus and suggested we might be in some form - but then the rest of the game happened.

O'Shea went invisible for periods in the game, which is always a sign we are not combining properly. Rojas, Mileusnic, Hore and Berenguer looked like they were struggling to make an impact over the whole of the game. I think Jelacic had one of the worst games I can remember - getting caught in possession time after time (thanks Cindy), lacking vision to see Macarthur closing him down, and seemingly trying to bumble the ball through challenges and failing - leaving Macarthur free behind him with the ball more often than not.

I think we miss Caletti in the midfield just being busy and a presence, and keeping the ball moving back and forth while also freeing up O'Shea to push forward when he wants to. Aldred and Hingert were out of the game for pace any time the ball came down our right hand side - and while I think Hingert did a fantastic job of battling skilful speed using experience and body strength, it is not any way to try and build a competitive series. To have two slower players trying to cover each other in that open space is a struggle for us and a guarantee that any team with speedy wingers has a chance to create down the wing unimpeded at some point.

Brown did pretty well today - ignoring his crosses that went beyond the back post to nobody - and created some opportunities for us. Trewin was his usual effective self but for some reason he made a few forward runs today that did not really add to our attacking strength and probably weakened our defence by having him out of the line. Burke-Gilroy came on for a short game on the right and demonstrated his speed when he tried to get back and help O'Shea stop Desilva in open space behind our defensive line on the fly. O'Shea did a great job of putting pressure on him so the shot was cactus, but Burke-Gilroy was eating up the ground trying to get there too.

Freke had another good game - with one excellent tip over early on particularly. At the ground I thought he should have come for the ball that gave them the second goal when it looped up high. Having never been a keeper I base that on nothing other than a feeling that he should have been on his toes and come out for it given how high it went.

Looking forward, we have a good understudy for Aldred in Nikolovski, but we still need a speedy right fullback, defensive mid, and striker to really be complete.

Macarthur's structure, individual skill and resilient defenders were just too good for us today. Good thing is, we have no easy games ahead so if we were to make the six we would have bloody well earned it.

Edit: Ballymore is a 'little ground' experience, with more comfortable seats than Suncorp but an inconvenience to get to. They put on free shuttle buses, but for me I had to drive to one train station to park the car, catch a train to another train station, walk the short walk to Perry Park, then shuttle bus to Ballymore. Just a bit more annoying than drive, park and walk to Suncorp. I think they said just over 3k in attendance - and no surprise in that really. Beef Burger cost over $16 for a meat patty, cheese, sliver of onion and mustard. Small cup of chips for $7. Did not enhance the experience for me. The little 'big screen' was pointless for replays with termites running round doing indeterminate stuff for the most part.

Always enjoy your detailed reports. Lucky for you being able to attend live AL football every fortnight in close  proximity! 

Younger players like Jelacic can be prone to inconsistency.

Watching the  game on TV it is interesting to note you thought Mac had better movement when in possession from your live vantage point? Do you think Mac Pressed and Squeezed more effectively than Roar to stifle Roar's passing lanes, hence disturbing Roar build ups more effectively?

Or were  Roar just more static in off the ball movement as they built up?
Edited
Last Year by Decentric 2
Decentric 2
Decentric 2
Pro
Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)Pro (3.3K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 3.1K, Visits: 0
Taggart scored again for Glory. 

Haven't seen any previous games with Vidmar on the bench for WU. 
Edited
Last Year by Decentric 2
charlied
charlied
Pro
Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 2.4K, Visits: 0
Roar in me Blood - 17 Mar 2024 5:50 PM
charlied - 17 Mar 2024 2:59 PM

I do not dispute the facts - just your intent by including him in your post.

I watch what he does. I agree that he is old enough to retire when he has had enough, but that does not mean he has no value on the pitch. He ran down a fresh Desilva yesterday and made him miss his shot. He still rarely loses the ball although he is getting teamed up on more often so it does happen. His vision and timing are still great.

I may have read more into your statement about his age than you intended by including him - but he is not a bolted on aging player so to me he does not belong in your overall statement about our squad.

If your intention was merely to say he is an older player then I agree with you. Any subsequent inference that it makes him not worth being on the pitch I dispute.

Yes, that was my intention and I recognise that I didn't express that clearly. 
Roar in me Blood
Roar in me Blood
World Class
World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 4.8K, Visits: 0
charlied - 17 Mar 2024 2:59 PM
Roar in me Blood - 17 Mar 2024 11:24 AM

O'shea is 35. That is, quite literally, at the end of his career as a footballer. Not only sure how to you can dispute that. 

I do not dispute the facts - just your intent by including him in your post.

I watch what he does. I agree that he is old enough to retire when he has had enough, but that does not mean he has no value on the pitch. He ran down a fresh Desilva yesterday and made him miss his shot. He still rarely loses the ball although he is getting teamed up on more often so it does happen. His vision and timing are still great.

I may have read more into your statement about his age than you intended by including him - but he is not a bolted on aging player so to me he does not belong in your overall statement about our squad.

If your intention was merely to say he is an older player then I agree with you. Any subsequent inference that it makes him not worth being on the pitch I dispute.

When I wear their colours, I am the club.

charlied
charlied
Pro
Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 2.4K, Visits: 0
Roar in me Blood - 17 Mar 2024 11:24 AM
Caletti's value to us is more that he gives a passing option through the middle to help move opposition players around than that he is a great player. He has the work engine and the work ethic needed to be there all game offering himself. We do not need him to be a great creative player to make a difference - that is what O'Shea does and Berenguer should be doing through midfield.

Berenguer has not really made a difference for us. I can't tell if that is age or that our playing style just doesn't suit what he brings. He has not really lifted us above what we had with other players in that role.

I disagree with you on O'Shea and think he has a lot to offer yet. Unfortunately, until we find a proper defensive mid we have to use him there and we lose the greater part of what he does - running freely where he sees the advantage and using his vision, skill and body to find options. He can still do that, but playing him deep in a defensive position limits his effectiveness.

Rojas may be at the end of his career but he has been showing great returns for us in the previous games. I am happy with him in the side and I have seen better play from him with us than I remember with him in Victory. He has been creating opportunities for himself and others, and he has been the instigator of a lot of positive plays.

Hingert was always a bit slower from memory but made up for it with his experience and willingness to run up and back all day. Having Neville inside has given us cover for his lack of pace and the injury to Scott has exposed us with Hingert and Aldred not up to speed literally. From our leftside being our greatest problem our rightside is now the weaker. When Fowler built our defensive group, I think he chose Aldred as a rock and Gillespie as our pace which turned out to be a good combination. We did not manage to replace Gillespie with a like-to-like player forcing Aldred to be both which he can't be.

Mileusnic is more odd. He still has pace and an engine, but we are not seeing as much of it lately.

Watching how Ruben has us playing I seem to see a lot more rotation of players on field. It means that Hore is our striker one minute then seemingly playing DM or fullback the next. Mileusnic's strength is out wide with pace, but we bring him through the middle just as often which is quite pointless with what he can do. Same for the other players - who have particular strengths and we only use them sporadically in games as Ruben has opted for a more fluid structure - presumably to mix it up and make it harder for defenders to know what they are facing. To me it makes the passer stop and think more and the receiver plays reactively and slower because they do not know what the passer is thinking. Personally I think that constant rotation of players disrupts our play and stops us from being able to build proper understanding and cohesion. The rotation might make defenders have to think but it does the same for our attack.

We are far from being a basketcase but still have a lot of growing into our game to do under Ruben. Plenty of positive play and potential in our side still with the game yesterday as a good example. I was not happy with how we played when we went the goal down but still recognise that we had the clear chances to win the game comfortably. A composed and able striker has been our cry out for many seasons. Does not mean we cannot be competitive or winners - just that we have to work that much harder to get there.

O'shea is 35. That is, quite literally, at the end of his career as a footballer. Not only sure how to you can dispute that. 
AnthonyC
AnthonyC
Amateur
Amateur (629 reputation)Amateur (629 reputation)Amateur (629 reputation)Amateur (629 reputation)Amateur (629 reputation)Amateur (629 reputation)Amateur (629 reputation)Amateur (629 reputation)Amateur (629 reputation)Amateur (629 reputation)Amateur (629 reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 611, Visits: 0
someguyjc - 16 Mar 2024 1:51 PM
banzai - 16 Mar 2024 4:44 AM

Thursday night is a factor. Cost of living is a factor. WU is a factor. 10 draws is a factor. 

What about the other no hopers in the comp. The poor football that they play has nothing to do with it? Many people on here think they can fool the others by saying this was great or that game was exciting because they know hardly anyone watches, but numbers are where the proof is. Even Harper admitted how shit the Brisbane defence was and that happens week in week out. Not just Roar but virtually every team.
Roar in me Blood
Roar in me Blood
World Class
World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 4.8K, Visits: 0
Caletti's value to us is more that he gives a passing option through the middle to help move opposition players around than that he is a great player. He has the work engine and the work ethic needed to be there all game offering himself. We do not need him to be a great creative player to make a difference - that is what O'Shea does and Berenguer should be doing through midfield.

Berenguer has not really made a difference for us. I can't tell if that is age or that our playing style just doesn't suit what he brings. He has not really lifted us above what we had with other players in that role.

I disagree with you on O'Shea and think he has a lot to offer yet. Unfortunately, until we find a proper defensive mid we have to use him there and we lose the greater part of what he does - running freely where he sees the advantage and using his vision, skill and body to find options. He can still do that, but playing him deep in a defensive position limits his effectiveness.

Rojas may be at the end of his career but he has been showing great returns for us in the previous games. I am happy with him in the side and I have seen better play from him with us than I remember with him in Victory. He has been creating opportunities for himself and others, and he has been the instigator of a lot of positive plays.

Hingert was always a bit slower from memory but made up for it with his experience and willingness to run up and back all day. Having Neville inside has given us cover for his lack of pace and the injury to Scott has exposed us with Hingert and Aldred not up to speed literally. From our leftside being our greatest problem our rightside is now the weaker. When Fowler built our defensive group, I think he chose Aldred as a rock and Gillespie as our pace which turned out to be a good combination. We did not manage to replace Gillespie with a like-to-like player forcing Aldred to be both which he can't be.

Mileusnic is more odd. He still has pace and an engine, but we are not seeing as much of it lately.

Watching how Ruben has us playing I seem to see a lot more rotation of players on field. It means that Hore is our striker one minute then seemingly playing DM or fullback the next. Mileusnic's strength is out wide with pace, but we bring him through the middle just as often which is quite pointless with what he can do. Same for the other players - who have particular strengths and we only use them sporadically in games as Ruben has opted for a more fluid structure - presumably to mix it up and make it harder for defenders to know what they are facing. To me it makes the passer stop and think more and the receiver plays reactively and slower because they do not know what the passer is thinking. Personally I think that constant rotation of players disrupts our play and stops us from being able to build proper understanding and cohesion. The rotation might make defenders have to think but it does the same for our attack.

We are far from being a basketcase but still have a lot of growing into our game to do under Ruben. Plenty of positive play and potential in our side still with the game yesterday as a good example. I was not happy with how we played when we went the goal down but still recognise that we had the clear chances to win the game comfortably. A composed and able striker has been our cry out for many seasons. Does not mean we cannot be competitive or winners - just that we have to work that much harder to get there.

When I wear their colours, I am the club.

charlied
charlied
Pro
Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)Pro (2.5K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 2.4K, Visits: 0
Roar in me Blood - 16 Mar 2024 7:56 PM
We got outplayed both individually and as a team.

Macarthur (grubby diving bastards) have better individual skills and today they played better team football too.

Watching them attack, when they chose to, they had 7 players streaming forward when in possession and passed the ball into space to the next running player. When we had the ball we had a ball carrier looking around, everyone standing flat footed in their 'attack positions' and one player who expected the ball up the wing running. We just could not put any consistent pressure on Macarthur's big, strong, skilled defenders the way we were playing.

That said - I remember 4 clear botched attempts at goals that should have all gone in. Two at the feet of our one dedicated striker (Waddingham) who had a shocker in front of goals and skied them both, one was a header directly between me and the goals with no-one in the line of the shot and we headed it wide, and the one miss hit gentle nudge along the ground that rolled towards the open goal and the keeper managed to get to it.

Got to say, scoring first in the opening 20 minutes was a bonus and suggested we might be in some form - but then the rest of the game happened.

O'Shea went invisible for periods in the game, which is always a sign we are not combining properly. Rojas, Mileusnic, Hore and Berenguer looked like they were struggling to make an impact over the whole of the game. I think Jelacic had one of the worst games I can remember - getting caught in possession time after time (thanks Cindy), lacking vision to see Macarthur closing him down, and seemingly trying to bumble the ball through challenges and failing - leaving Macarthur free behind him with the ball more often than not.

I think we miss Caletti in the midfield just being busy and a presence, and keeping the ball moving back and forth while also freeing up O'Shea to push forward when he wants to. Aldred and Hingert were out of the game for pace any time the ball came down our right hand side - and while I think Hingert did a fantastic job of battling skilful speed using experience and body strength, it is not any way to try and build a competitive series. To have two slower players trying to cover each other in that open space is a struggle for us and a guarantee that any team with speedy wingers has a chance to create down the wing unimpeded at some point.

Brown did pretty well today - ignoring his crosses that went beyond the back post to nobody - and created some opportunities for us. Trewin was his usual effective self but for some reason he made a few forward runs today that did not really add to our attacking strength and probably weakened our defence by having him out of the line. Burke-Gilroy came on for a short game on the right and demonstrated his speed when he tried to get back and help O'Shea stop Desilva in open space behind our defensive line on the fly. O'Shea did a great job of putting pressure on him so the shot was cactus, but Burke-Gilroy was eating up the ground trying to get there too.

Freke had another good game - with one excellent tip over early on particularly. At the ground I thought he should have come for the ball that gave them the second goal when it looped up high. Having never been a keeper I base that on nothing other than a feeling that he should have been on his toes and come out for it given how high it went.

Looking forward, we have a good understudy for Aldred in Nikolovski, but we still need a speedy right fullback, defensive mid, and striker to really be complete.

Macarthur's structure, individual skill and resilient defenders were just too good for us today. Good thing is, we have no easy games ahead so if we were to make the six we would have bloody well earned it.

Edit: Ballymore is a 'little ground' experience, with more comfortable seats than Suncorp but an inconvenience to get to. They put on free shuttle buses, but for me I had to drive to one train station to park the car, catch a train to another train station, walk the short walk to Perry Park, then shuttle bus to Ballymore. Just a bit more annoying than drive, park and walk to Suncorp. I think they said just over 3k in attendance - and no surprise in that really. Beef Burger cost over $16 for a meat patty, cheese, sliver of onion and mustard. Small cup of chips for $7. Did not enhance the experience for me. The little 'big screen' was pointless for replays with termites running round doing indeterminate stuff for the most part.

Let's face it, RIMB — Any team relying on a player of Caletti's limitations to make a difference is in trouble. I would say the same, frankly, about a team still selecting Hingert as a starting player. O"Shea is at the very end of his career, Berenguer and Rojas and Hingert too. . Milusenic is 30 and a pure pace player so nearing the end. Caletti simply not up to standard. So many bolt on aging players. The squad needs a major rebuild. HUJ

grazorblade
grazorblade
Legend
Legend (20K reputation)Legend (20K reputation)Legend (20K reputation)Legend (20K reputation)Legend (20K reputation)Legend (20K reputation)Legend (20K reputation)Legend (20K reputation)Legend (20K reputation)Legend (20K reputation)Legend (20K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 19K, Visits: 0
Mark rudan says that he doesnt believe a coach can lose a dressing room

To be fair to him, its something ive heard fans say but has there ever been a confirmed concrete case of that?

Closest i can think of was arnie saying in 07 the players tripped him as a joke in training 
SUTHERLANDBEAR
SUTHERLANDBEAR
Pro
Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 3.3K, Visits: 0
Balin Trev - 16 Mar 2024 9:59 PM
SUTHERLANDBEAR - 16 Mar 2024 8:59 PM

Instead of splitting hairs on an internet forum get a fucking life you sad piece of shit

Says you, you don't do irony much, do you ?:P:P:P
Balin Trev
Balin Trev
Pro
Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 3.7K, Visits: 0
SUTHERLANDBEAR - 16 Mar 2024 8:59 PM
Balin Trev - 16 Mar 2024 8:48 PM

You obviously do,by making comments about it. Get back to your Aussie rules game.

Instead of splitting hairs on an internet forum get a fucking life you sad piece of shit
SUTHERLANDBEAR
SUTHERLANDBEAR
Pro
Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 3.3K, Visits: 0
Balin Trev - 16 Mar 2024 8:48 PM
SUTHERLANDBEAR - 16 Mar 2024 8:35 PM

Seriously who gives a fuck

You obviously do,by making comments about it. Get back to your Aussie rules game.
Balin Trev
Balin Trev
Pro
Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)Pro (4K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 3.7K, Visits: 0
SUTHERLANDBEAR - 16 Mar 2024 8:35 PM
Balin Trev - 16 Mar 2024 6:58 PM

That wasn’t what you said though, you said the whole country.

Seriously who gives a fuck
SUTHERLANDBEAR
SUTHERLANDBEAR
Pro
Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)Pro (3.4K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 3.3K, Visits: 0
Balin Trev - 16 Mar 2024 6:58 PM
SUTHERLANDBEAR - 16 Mar 2024 6:26 PM

Auckland has population of 1.6 million. Think they can manage 

That wasn’t what you said though, you said the whole country.
Roar in me Blood
Roar in me Blood
World Class
World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)World Class (5.1K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 4.8K, Visits: 0
We got outplayed both individually and as a team.

Macarthur (grubby diving bastards) have better individual skills and today they played better team football too.

Watching them attack, when they chose to, they had 7 players streaming forward when in possession and passed the ball into space to the next running player. When we had the ball we had a ball carrier looking around, everyone standing flat footed in their 'attack positions' and one player who expected the ball up the wing running. We just could not put any consistent pressure on Macarthur's big, strong, skilled defenders the way we were playing.

That said - I remember 4 clear botched attempts at goals that should have all gone in. Two at the feet of our one dedicated striker (Waddingham) who had a shocker in front of goals and skied them both, one was a header directly between me and the goals with no-one in the line of the shot and we headed it wide, and the one miss hit gentle nudge along the ground that rolled towards the open goal and the keeper managed to get to it.

Got to say, scoring first in the opening 20 minutes was a bonus and suggested we might be in some form - but then the rest of the game happened.

O'Shea went invisible for periods in the game, which is always a sign we are not combining properly. Rojas, Mileusnic, Hore and Berenguer looked like they were struggling to make an impact over the whole of the game. I think Jelacic had one of the worst games I can remember - getting caught in possession time after time (thanks Cindy), lacking vision to see Macarthur closing him down, and seemingly trying to bumble the ball through challenges and failing - leaving Macarthur free behind him with the ball more often than not.

I think we miss Caletti in the midfield just being busy and a presence, and keeping the ball moving back and forth while also freeing up O'Shea to push forward when he wants to. Aldred and Hingert were out of the game for pace any time the ball came down our right hand side - and while I think Hingert did a fantastic job of battling skilful speed using experience and body strength, it is not any way to try and build a competitive series. To have two slower players trying to cover each other in that open space is a struggle for us and a guarantee that any team with speedy wingers has a chance to create down the wing unimpeded at some point.

Brown did pretty well today - ignoring his crosses that went beyond the back post to nobody - and created some opportunities for us. Trewin was his usual effective self but for some reason he made a few forward runs today that did not really add to our attacking strength and probably weakened our defence by having him out of the line. Burke-Gilroy came on for a short game on the right and demonstrated his speed when he tried to get back and help O'Shea stop Desilva in open space behind our defensive line on the fly. O'Shea did a great job of putting pressure on him so the shot was cactus, but Burke-Gilroy was eating up the ground trying to get there too.

Freke had another good game - with one excellent tip over early on particularly. At the ground I thought he should have come for the ball that gave them the second goal when it looped up high. Having never been a keeper I base that on nothing other than a feeling that he should have been on his toes and come out for it given how high it went.

Looking forward, we have a good understudy for Aldred in Nikolovski, but we still need a speedy right fullback, defensive mid, and striker to really be complete.

Macarthur's structure, individual skill and resilient defenders were just too good for us today. Good thing is, we have no easy games ahead so if we were to make the six we would have bloody well earned it.

Edit: Ballymore is a 'little ground' experience, with more comfortable seats than Suncorp but an inconvenience to get to. They put on free shuttle buses, but for me I had to drive to one train station to park the car, catch a train to another train station, walk the short walk to Perry Park, then shuttle bus to Ballymore. Just a bit more annoying than drive, park and walk to Suncorp. I think they said just over 3k in attendance - and no surprise in that really. Beef Burger cost over $16 for a meat patty, cheese, sliver of onion and mustard. Small cup of chips for $7. Did not enhance the experience for me. The little 'big screen' was pointless for replays with termites running round doing indeterminate stuff for the most part.

When I wear their colours, I am the club.

Edited
Last Year by Roar in me Blood
GO


Select a Forum....























Inside Sport


Search