Promotion /relegation will it work ???

Back

Promotion /relegation will it work ???

Author	Message
SydneyUnited	SydneyUnited Posted 12 Years Ago #1657460
Hacker Group: Forum Members Posts: 338, Visits: 0	What are your thoughts on a promotion / relegation system in the a-league. For example now that the apl is up and running A-league Apl - conferences In 5-10 years time A-league 12-14 teams A-2 league 8-12 teams Apl conferences Okay now I have an idea how the a-league can keep big cities in the top two tiers. For example if say a Sydney team finishes bottom of a-2 they can only be replaced by the winner of that conference. That will keep the same number or evenly distributed teams throughout the top two tiers. What are your thoughts ?
	Reply

Threaded View

Promotion /relegation will it work ???

SydneyUnited - 12 Years Ago

Also I'd like to ask a mod if they could make this a dedicated...

SydneyUnited - 12 Years Ago

No. Will kill off any team that gets relegated, have promotion of the...

YerNathanael - 12 Years Ago

sounds pretty good to me. im intrigued at the strategy and direction...

switters - 12 Years Ago

the bottom placed team should play over 2 legs, if an A2 team can win...

switters - 12 Years Ago

It won't e easy, but if we can keep the same number of teams per state...

SydneyUnited - 12 Years Ago

YerNathanael wrote: No. Will kill off any team that gets relegated,...

Cool_Cat2007 - 12 Years Ago

A-1 - a-2 is simple bottom placed plays off against winner of a-2 2nd...

SydneyUnited - 12 Years Ago

Important thing is to keep it simple, none of this A team only gets...

rusty - 12 Years Ago

rusty wrote: Important thing is to keep it simple, none of this A...

SydneyUnited - 12 Years Ago

Utterly ridiculous

lukerobinho - 12 Years Ago

Cool_Cat2007 wrote: YerNathanael wrote: No. Will kill off any...

Axelv - 12 Years Ago

In the far far far far future maybe, any P/R would have to have a 2nd...

Glory Recruit - 12 Years Ago

Under the current outline, you'll only have a club go up every decade...

notorganic - 12 Years Ago

All sounds so good in theory but the reality is that this will not...

Heart_fan - 12 Years Ago

Honestly think it can work, but not in the immediate future. Club...

Scoll - 12 Years Ago

YerNathanael wrote: No. Will kill off any team that gets relegated...

liverpoolfan2010 - 12 Years Ago

SydneyUnited wrote: A-1 - a-2 is simple bottom placed plays off...

Nautical Themed Pashmina Afghan - 12 Years Ago

Heart_fan wrote: All sounds so good in theory but the reality is...

GDeathe - 12 Years Ago

Axelv wrote: Cool_Cat2007 wrote: YerNathanael wrote: No. Will...

KiwiChick1 - 12 Years Ago

Axelv wrote: Cool_Cat2007 wrote: YerNathanael wrote: No. Will...

FulofGladbach - 12 Years Ago

Axelv wrote: Cool_Cat2007 wrote: YerNathanael wrote: No. Will...

Gyfox - 12 Years Ago

People are forgetting that I included only teams being relegated from...

SydneyUnited - 12 Years Ago

It won't work. No other country in the world has 5 major billion...

Roar #1 - 12 Years Ago

no relegation, only promotion until we get to 16 clubs with strict...

williamn - 12 Years Ago

williamn wrote: no relegation, only promotion until we get to 16...

Roar #1 - 12 Years Ago

williamn wrote: no relegation, only promotion until we get to 16...

Gyfox - 12 Years Ago

For now, no. It would fail miserably. We need to focus on building the...

JayEss - 12 Years Ago

I am of the opinion that while Australia may be able to create a...

macktheknife - 12 Years Ago

Roar #1 wrote: williamn wrote: no relegation, only promotion...

Gyfox - 12 Years Ago

IMO, they should allow maybe two state league clubs into the A-League...

Freddie AppsHero - 12 Years Ago

Freddie AppsHero wrote: IMO, they should allow maybe two state...

Roar #1 - 12 Years Ago

Freddie AppsHero wrote: IMO, they should allow maybe two state...

Gyfox - 12 Years Ago

Roar #1 wrote: Freddie AppsHero wrote: IMO, they should allow...

Freddie AppsHero - 12 Years Ago

Heres a Idea: Have a last from a1 vs first from a2 play-off to please...

GGfortythree - 12 Years Ago

Football is not big enough here yet and not enough supporters to have...

liverpoolfan2010 - 12 Years Ago

Smell the fear. As soon as a club goes down it's abandon ship for...

KenGooner_GCU - 12 Years Ago

KenGooner_GCU wrote: Smell the fear. As soon as a club goes down...

davidbloop - 12 Years Ago

davidbloop wrote: KenGooner_GCU wrote: Smell the fear. As soon...

KenGooner_GCU - 12 Years Ago

HERE HERE macktheknife,=d> =d> =d> The only way prom/reg...

lolitsbigmic - 12 Years Ago

KenGooner_GCU wrote: Smell the fear. As soon as a club goes down...

patjennings - 12 Years Ago

One problem with a lot of negative assumptions about a second...

blacka - 12 Years Ago

No, it will not work in our lifetime. Most A-league clubs are in...

stefcep - 12 Years Ago

Firstly, Promotion/Relegation will just not work in Australia. We are...

Red_or_Dead - 12 Years Ago

The finals series is Australia's version of pro/rel.

Roar #1 - 12 Years Ago

Roar #1 wrote: The finals series is Australia's version of pro/rel....

Glory Recruit - 12 Years Ago

Aussie4ever4 wrote: Roar #1 wrote: The finals series is...

lolitsbigmic - 12 Years Ago

The thing that all of the recent debate about promotion/relegation...

Benjamin - 12 Years Ago

South Melbourne didn't get relegated, they just didnt get invited, you...

Glory Recruit - 12 Years Ago

patjennings wrote: KenGooner_GCU wrote: Smell the fear. As soon...

General Ashnak - 12 Years Ago

Benjamin wrote: The thing that all of the recent debate about...

macktheknife - 12 Years Ago

Benjamin wrote: The thing that all of the recent debate about...

General Ashnak - 12 Years Ago

General Ashnak wrote: patjennings wrote: KenGooner_GCU wrote:...

macktheknife - 12 Years Ago

General Ashnak wrote: Benjamin wrote: The thing that all of the...

macktheknife - 12 Years Ago

macktheknife wrote: General Ashnak wrote: patjennings wrote:...

General Ashnak - 12 Years Ago

Mackontheattack! it rhymes, i like it, i should be a poet.

Glory Recruit - 12 Years Ago

So far the only argument against is fear, no matter how you try and...

General Ashnak - 12 Years Ago

Benjamin wrote: The thing that all of the recent debate about...

rusty - 12 Years Ago

Aussie4ever4 wrote: South Melbourne didn't get relegated , they...

Benjamin - 12 Years Ago

General Ashnak wrote: So far the only argument against is fear, no...

Roar #1 - 12 Years Ago

rusty wrote: Benjamin wrote: The thing that all of the recent...

Benjamin - 12 Years Ago

Say for example we got rid of the salary cap, the big city clubs would...

SydneyUnited - 12 Years Ago

Sorry but what is a community club?

Glory Recruit - 12 Years Ago

General Ashnak wrote: So far the only argument against is fear, no...

macktheknife - 12 Years Ago

Aussie4ever4 wrote: Sorry but what is a community club? Id go as...

SydneyUnited - 12 Years Ago

Imagine a team from an isolated area such as wagga wagga gaining...

SydneyUnited - 12 Years Ago

I think we should just get to 14/16 teams and then raise the salary...

Roar #1 - 12 Years Ago

SydneyUnited wrote: Aussie4ever4 wrote: Sorry but what is a...

Glory Recruit - 12 Years Ago

FWIW I think promotion and relegation can definitely work (sooner...

rusty - 12 Years Ago

I think it's a matter of money over everything. We possibly have...

Roar #1 - 12 Years Ago

rusty wrote: P&R is the heartbeat of all thriving football...

Roar #1 - 12 Years Ago

Roar #1 wrote: rusty wrote: P&R is the heartbeat of all...

rusty - 12 Years Ago

rusty wrote: Roar #1 wrote: rusty wrote: P&R is the...

Roar #1 - 12 Years Ago

rusty wrote: Roar #1 wrote: rusty wrote: P&R is the...

macktheknife - 12 Years Ago

In 30 years time we could have two 14 team divisions. If we have p/r...

scubaroo - 12 Years Ago

Roar #1 wrote: But the clubs survive on TV deals. There is already...

rusty - 12 Years Ago

Roar #1 wrote: I think it's a matter of money over everything. We...

KenGooner_GCU - 12 Years Ago

rusty wrote: Roar #1 wrote: But the clubs survive on TV deals....

Roar #1 - 12 Years Ago

How about this? Set up the league so that you have ten teams in each...

clockwork orange - 12 Years Ago

Roar #1 wrote: rusty wrote: Roar #1 wrote: But the clubs...

rusty - 12 Years Ago

Gyfox wrote: Freddie AppsHero wrote: IMO, they should allow...

HiReception - 12 Years Ago

rusty wrote: Roar #1 wrote: rusty wrote: Roar #1 wrote:...

KenGooner_GCU - 12 Years Ago

YerNathanael wrote: No. Will kill off any team that gets relegated,...

lardface - 12 Years Ago

Aussie4ever4 wrote: In the far far far far future maybe, any P/R...

lardface - 12 Years Ago

From what has been said the NPL (now that it's the NPL) is being...

Someguy - 12 Years Ago

lardface wrote: YerNathanael wrote: No. Will kill off any team...

bubbling11 - 12 Years Ago

Promotion/relegation wouldn't work because if Brisbane Roar got...

paulbagzFC - 12 Years Ago

Axelv wrote: Cool_Cat2007 wrote: YerNathanael wrote: No. Will...

StiflersMom - 12 Years Ago

paulbagzFC wrote: Promotion/relegation wouldn't work because if...

Someguy - 12 Years Ago

bubbling11 wrote: lardface wrote: YerNathanael wrote: No....

lardface - 12 Years Ago

lardface wrote: bubbling11 wrote: lardface wrote:...

Someguy - 12 Years Ago

lardface wrote: YerNathanael wrote: No. Will kill off any team...

stefcep - 12 Years Ago

macktheknife wrote: General Ashnak wrote: patjennings wrote:...

Arthur - 12 Years Ago

On the topic of promotion and relegation, lets throw in the NPL all...

Arthur - 12 Years Ago

P/R should eventually be introduced. It will sort out the wheat from...

jak - 12 Years Ago

Arthur wrote: As far as I'm concerned Ben Buckley did none of this...

Benjamin - 12 Years Ago

davidbloop wrote: KenGooner_GCU wrote: Smell the fear. As soon...

GCU till I die - 12 Years Ago

StiflersMom wrote: Here's a more ridiculous thought, how about if...

GCU till I die - 12 Years Ago

GCU till I die wrote: davidbloop wrote: KenGooner_GCU wrote:...

lardface - 12 Years Ago

lardface wrote: GCU till I die wrote: davidbloop wrote:...

GCU till I die - 12 Years Ago

Arthur wrote: On the topic of promotion and relegation, lets throw...

macktheknife - 12 Years Ago

Promotion/relegation might not happen now but could very well happen...

Timmo - 12 Years Ago

macktheknife wrote: Arthur wrote: On the topic of promotion and...

Benjamin - 12 Years Ago

Ignoring all of the other problems/potential problems with...

petszk - 12 Years Ago

Yes - it can work. [if by work you mean the league struggles along...

Mister Football - 12 Years Ago

Benjamin wrote: macktheknife wrote: Arthur wrote: On the...

Roar #1 - 12 Years Ago

Timmo wrote: The only main issue I can see is this WHEN WILL YOU...

Benjamin - 12 Years Ago

Roar #1 wrote: =; [-x :roll: then what's the point of pro/rel...

Benjamin - 12 Years Ago

GCU till I die wrote: lardface wrote: GCU till I die wrote:...

paulbagzFC - 12 Years Ago

Benjamin wrote: Roar #1 wrote: =; [-x :roll: then what's the...

Roar #1 - 12 Years Ago

Benjamin wrote: One could go a step further... Set up the A2 for...

Mister Football - 12 Years Ago

promotion relegation isn't worth that many points in the acl. Its not...

grazorblade - 12 Years Ago

Roar #1 wrote: Benjamin wrote: Roar #1 wrote: =; [-x :roll:...

Benjamin - 12 Years Ago

Benjamin wrote: macktheknife wrote: Arthur wrote: On the...

macktheknife - 12 Years Ago

Can and will work. If the second division remains conference. Simple....

TheSelectFew - 12 Years Ago

Mister Football wrote: Benjamin wrote: One could go a step...

GCU till I die - 12 Years Ago

macktheknife wrote: Yet again you mistake a desire for an 18 or 20...

Benjamin - 12 Years Ago

Mister Football wrote: Benjamin wrote: One could go a step...

Benjamin - 12 Years Ago

I agree with the people who say we shouldn't be like Europe. This is...

torcida90 - 12 Years Ago

Benjamin wrote: macktheknife wrote: Yet again you mistake a...

macktheknife - 12 Years Ago

General Ashnak wrote: patjennings wrote: KenGooner_GCU wrote:...

Axelv - 12 Years Ago

Axelv wrote: What would happen to the Television ratings if Sydney...

GCU till I die - 12 Years Ago

I think that PR will eventually work. What probably needs to happen...

hotrod - 12 Years Ago

So we get 3 months of a team 'fighting to stay up' and then what next...

macktheknife - 12 Years Ago

GCU till I die wrote: Axelv wrote: What would happen to the...

Axelv - 12 Years Ago

P + R can work but only if football is the absolute number one sport...

beersandwich - 12 Years Ago

Why MUST we have a national 2nd division. Why not make it regional...

TheSelectFew - 12 Years Ago

Promotion will work. That's how the A league can grow to 12 then 14...

Burztur - 12 Years Ago

Burztur wrote: Promotion will work. That's how the A league can...

TheSelectFew - 12 Years Ago

The chances of SFC, WSW or MV being relegated in an uncapped league...

blacka - 12 Years Ago

beersandwich wrote: P + R can work but only if football is the...

Mister Football - 12 Years Ago

Burztur wrote: Promotion will work. That's how the A league can...

Mister Football - 12 Years Ago

macktheknife wrote: So we get 3 months of a team 'fighting to stay...

GCU till I die - 12 Years Ago

If my team gets relegated...I'd go to the game. If second tier...

TheSelectFew - 12 Years Ago

Have you even made one post on Melbourne victory, all your posts seem...

Glory Recruit - 12 Years Ago

Aussie4ever4 wrote: Have you even made one post on Melbourne...

TheSelectFew - 12 Years Ago

TheSelectFew wrote: Aussie4ever4 wrote: Have you even made one...

Glory Recruit - 12 Years Ago

Aussie4ever4 wrote: TheSelectFew wrote: Aussie4ever4 wrote:...

TheSelectFew - 12 Years Ago

TheSelectFew wrote: If my team gets relegated...I'd go to the game....

jak - 12 Years Ago

GCU till I die wrote: macktheknife wrote: So we get 3 months of...

petszk - 12 Years Ago

petszk wrote: GCU till I die wrote: macktheknife wrote: So we...

KenGooner_GCU - 12 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] KenGooner_GCU - 15 Feb 2013 8:02 PM [/b]...

numklpkgulftumch - 3 Years Ago

How will Sydney FC = rich, no chance of relegation in an uncapped...

SydneyUnited - 12 Years Ago

Example adelaide united come last, no one cars they get 7,000 to each...

SydneyUnited - 12 Years Ago

KenGooner_GCU wrote: petszk wrote: GCU till I die wrote:...

petszk - 12 Years Ago

This could be the National Premier League Canberra - Bruce or Manuka...

rusty - 12 Years Ago

I think Promotion/relegation should stay between like for like...

Benchwarmer - 12 Years Ago

jak wrote: TheSelectFew wrote: If my team gets relegated...I'd...

TheSelectFew - 12 Years Ago

Benchwarmer wrote: I think Promotion/relegation should stay between...

TheSelectFew - 12 Years Ago

Benchwarmer wrote: I think Promotion/relegation should stay between...

Joffa - 12 Years Ago

jak wrote: TheSelectFew wrote: If my team gets relegated...I'd...

stefcep - 12 Years Ago

petszk wrote: KenGooner_GCU wrote: petszk wrote: GCU till I...

KenGooner_GCU - 12 Years Ago

KenGooner_GCU wrote: petszk wrote: KenGooner_GCU wrote:...

TheSelectFew - 12 Years Ago

TheSelectFew wrote: Benchwarmer wrote: I think...

Benjamin - 12 Years Ago

I can see positives and negatives on both sides, good discussion....

krisskrash - 12 Years Ago

stefcep wrote: jak wrote: TheSelectFew wrote: If my team gets...

jak - 12 Years Ago

I'd like to see: Last - First = Automatic P/R 2nd last - 2nd runner...

Mulhollanddrive - 12 Years Ago

krisskrash wrote: I can see positives and negatives on both sides,...

Benjamin - 12 Years Ago

Whether for or against promotion or relegation the main thing I am...

Timmo - 12 Years Ago

Timmo wrote: Whether for or against promotion or relegation the...

Benjamin - 12 Years Ago

Spot on Benjamin I think we can all agree pro/rel has so many...

SydneyUnited - 12 Years Ago

Benjamin wrote: TheSelectFew wrote: Benchwarmer wrote: I...

lost - 12 Years Ago

lost wrote: I like your reasoning for a 12 team 2nd tier comp Ben....

Benjamin - 12 Years Ago

Stuttgart score 92nd minute to avoid relegation. This is the magic of...

tsf - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] tsf - 15 May 2022 8:43 PM [/b]...

GDeathe - 3 Years Ago

A lot of names on this thread that we haven't seen for a long time.

bettega - 3 Years Ago

YES pro/rel will work.

Stenson - 3 Years Ago

We still have a way to go but with the NPL clubs finally having a...

AyyLeague - 3 Years Ago

for an organisation focused on metrics (or that used to be) it seems...

tsf - 3 Years Ago

Had this on my mind for a while, but here is an argument for why, even...

df1982 - 3 Years Ago

Found it pretty cool that a small club in Scotland called Queens Park...

aussie pride - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] aussie pride - 16 May 2022 9:04 PM [/b]...

Monoethnic Social Club - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] aussie pride - 16 May 2022 9:04 PM [/b]...

dr. bellows - 3 Years Ago

:w00t: :laugh: Hey long time between the efffnicks probs they bring...

LFC. - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] Monoethnic Social Club - 17 May 2022...

AyyLeague - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] AyyLeague - 17 May 2022 9:18 PM [/b]...

Monoethnic Social Club - 3 Years Ago

Will the FA/APL want to promote clubs from a Foreign Heritage or...

soccerfoo - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] soccerfoo - 17 May 2022 6:11 PM [/b]...

Monoethnic Social Club - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] Monoethnic Social Club - 17 May 2022...

Stenson - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] Stenson - 18 May 2022 5:56 AM [/b]...

Monoethnic Social Club - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] Monoethnic Social Club - 18 May 2022...

Stenson - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] Stenson - 18 May 2022 2:12 PM [/b]...

Monoethnic Social Club - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] Monoethnic Social Club - 18 May 2022...

Stenson - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] Stenson - 18 May 2022 7:33 PM [/b]...

Monoethnic Social Club - 3 Years Ago

P & R will never work in Australia. It would scare away the major...

Johns - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] Johns - 17 May 2022 6:59 PM [/b] P &...

Monoethnic Social Club - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] Johns - 17 May 2022 6:59 PM [/b] P &...

df1982 - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] df1982 - 18 May 2022 6:15 AM [/b]...

Monoethnic Social Club - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] df1982 - 18 May 2022 6:15 AM [/b]...

Butler99 - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] Butler99 - 18 May 2022 4:53 PM [/b]...

df1982 - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] Johns - 17 May 2022 6:59 PM [/b] P &...

Munrubenmuz - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] Munrubenmuz - 18 May 2022 8:06 AM [/b]...

petszk - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] petszk - 20 May 2022 3:20 PM [/b]...

someguyjc - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] petszk - 20 May 2022 3:20 PM [/b]...

Munrubenmuz - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] Johns - 17 May 2022 6:59 PM [/b] P &...

numklpkgulftumch - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] Johns - 17 May 2022 6:59 PM [/b] P &...

tomw - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] Johns - 17 May 2022 6:59 PM [/b] P &...

tsf - 3 Years Ago

i disagree with concept that the a-league should expand to 14-16...

simione001 - 3 Years Ago

In the very early years of organised football in England the southern...

Gyfox - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] Gyfox - 18 May 2022 3:14 PM [/b] In...

Monoethnic Social Club - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] Monoethnic Social Club - 18 May 2022...

LFC. - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] LFC. - 19 May 2022 3:13 PM [/b] +...

Monoethnic Social Club - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] LFC. - 19 May 2022 3:13 PM [/b] +...

Gyfox - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] Gyfox - 21 May 2022 5:04 PM [/b] +...

Munrubenmuz - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] Munrubenmuz - 21 May 2022 6:00 PM [/b]...

Gyfox - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] Gyfox - 21 May 2022 11:45 PM [/b]...

Monoethnic Social Club - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] Monoethnic Social Club - 21 May 2022...

Gyfox - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] Monoethnic Social Club - 17 May 2022...

AyyLeague - 3 Years Ago

With the ALM moving to a 14 team competition next season and the NSD...

libelous - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] libelous - 21 May 2022 6:23 PM [/b]...

soccerfoo - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] soccerfoo - 21 May 2022 7:41 PM [/b]...

LFC. - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] LFC. - 23 May 2022 12:38 PM [/b] +...

Monoethnic Social Club - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] Monoethnic Social Club - 23 May 2022...

someguyjc - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] someguyjc - 23 May 2022 3:32 PM [/b]...

Monoethnic Social Club - 3 Years Ago

+ x [quote] [b] libelous - 21 May 2022 6:23 PM [/b]...

Monoethnic Social Club - 3 Years Ago

In terms of p&r the National Second-division League (NSL) and NPLs is...

GDeathe - 3 Years Ago

P&R can work here but as always, it needs to be managed well. It is...

Heart_fan - 3 Years Ago

If in 20 years, the only teams in the the top flight are only...

TheDjentleman - 3 Years Ago

We have lived without a Tasmanian team since the A League started. Its...

Footballking55 - 3 Years Ago

touch wood we get the news in that case after the coming GF.

LFC. - 3 Years Ago