Would Promotion & Relegation actually work in Australian Football ?


Would Promotion & Relegation actually work in Australian Football ?

Author
Message
paulbagzFC
paulbagzFC
Legend
Legend (45K reputation)Legend (45K reputation)Legend (45K reputation)Legend (45K reputation)Legend (45K reputation)Legend (45K reputation)Legend (45K reputation)Legend (45K reputation)Legend (45K reputation)Legend (45K reputation)Legend (45K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 44K, Visits: 0
paulc - 7 Nov 2018 12:34 PM

It's such a relief to know there are so many world renowned, brilliant award winning accountants specializing in the commerciality of sport on this forum.

How could football go wrong.


We can't all have PHDs in ethnic studies mate.

-PB

https://i.imgur.com/batge7K.jpg

lost
lost
Hardcore Fan
Hardcore Fan (219 reputation)Hardcore Fan (219 reputation)Hardcore Fan (219 reputation)Hardcore Fan (219 reputation)Hardcore Fan (219 reputation)Hardcore Fan (219 reputation)Hardcore Fan (219 reputation)Hardcore Fan (219 reputation)Hardcore Fan (219 reputation)Hardcore Fan (219 reputation)Hardcore Fan (219 reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 210, Visits: 0
An A league cup at the start of each season would give the profile of the 2nd division a leg up. If there was 12 teams in each of the A league and A league 2 divisions, a preseaon cup featuring 4 groups of 6 teams (with 50/50 split of A1 and A2 teams in each group) would provide 5 matches for all involved. With the top 2 in each group progressing to knockout stages, the cup would be wrapped up in 8 weeks. I expect that there would be enough interest to have this televised. We would get a yearly measure of the gap between A1 and A2 to aid in the decision of when promotion and relegation is realistic. There would be enough games per year to reduced each league to home and away. WIn - win.
Blew.2
Blew.2
Rising Star
Rising Star (776 reputation)Rising Star (776 reputation)Rising Star (776 reputation)Rising Star (776 reputation)Rising Star (776 reputation)Rising Star (776 reputation)Rising Star (776 reputation)Rising Star (776 reputation)Rising Star (776 reputation)Rising Star (776 reputation)Rising Star (776 reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 753, Visits: 0
lost - 8 Nov 2018 8:00 AM
An A league cup at the start of each season would give the profile of the 2nd division a leg up. If there was 12 teams in each of the A league and A league 2 divisions, a preseaon cup featuring 4 groups of 6 teams (with 50/50 split of A1 and A2 teams in each group) would provide 5 matches for all involved. With the top 2 in each group progressing to knockout stages, the cup would be wrapped up in 8 weeks. I expect that there would be enough interest to have this televised. We would get a yearly measure of the gap between A1 and A2 to aid in the decision of when promotion and relegation is realistic. There would be enough games per year to reduced each league to home and away. WIn - win.

Don't they call it the FFA Cup

Clear Contact There

Bryn FC
Bryn FC
Fan
Fan (81 reputation)Fan (81 reputation)Fan (81 reputation)Fan (81 reputation)Fan (81 reputation)Fan (81 reputation)Fan (81 reputation)Fan (81 reputation)Fan (81 reputation)Fan (81 reputation)Fan (81 reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 77, Visits: 0
lost - 8 Nov 2018 8:00 AM
An A league cup at the start of each season would give the profile of the 2nd division a leg up. If there was 12 teams in each of the A league and A league 2 divisions, a preseaon cup featuring 4 groups of 6 teams (with 50/50 split of A1 and A2 teams in each group) would provide 5 matches for all involved. With the top 2 in each group progressing to knockout stages, the cup would be wrapped up in 8 weeks. I expect that there would be enough interest to have this televised. We would get a yearly measure of the gap between A1 and A2 to aid in the decision of when promotion and relegation is realistic. There would be enough games per year to reduced each league to home and away. WIn - win.

This could work, it gives the teams more time to prepare for the FFA cup as well.

it would nice to see A2 vs A1, to see the progress in a controlled environment, another option is to play these during the International week, as the A2 clubs won't mind, and it give the fringe players in the A league teams to get game time.

and as a pun, lets call it the Milk cup, A1 protein vs A2 Protein sponsored by the dairy industry:D





paulc
paulc
Legend
Legend (16K reputation)Legend (16K reputation)Legend (16K reputation)Legend (16K reputation)Legend (16K reputation)Legend (16K reputation)Legend (16K reputation)Legend (16K reputation)Legend (16K reputation)Legend (16K reputation)Legend (16K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 15K, Visits: 0
paulbagzFC - 7 Nov 2018 10:53 PM
paulc - 7 Nov 2018 12:34 PM

We can't all have PHDs in ethnic studies mate.

-PB

https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSMrIFVHDahZrLIWPnYNtAV-3i8hyUrRcSU05u4LX-HNRS7-oK3


In a resort somewhere

P&R will fix it 2.0
P&R will fix it 2.0
Pro
Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 4.8K, Visits: 0
Watford Fans banner yesterday

Image result for Watford banner


Closed HAL is failing with 10 teams
Closed HAL failed with 11
FFA forced to try a 12 team Closed HAL thatll just create 2 more mid table also-rans
and still this weird 16-team panacea gets trotted out. 
Theres a sticky for this nonsense
https://forum.insidesport.com.au/1617388/The-Aleague-Expansion-Thread

azzaMVFC
azzaMVFC
World Class
World Class (6.5K reputation)World Class (6.5K reputation)World Class (6.5K reputation)World Class (6.5K reputation)World Class (6.5K reputation)World Class (6.5K reputation)World Class (6.5K reputation)World Class (6.5K reputation)World Class (6.5K reputation)World Class (6.5K reputation)World Class (6.5K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 6.3K, Visits: 0
Establishing a second division and working towards promotion and relegation needs to be the highest priority.
The league is dying a slow death at the moment, even though the football played on the park is of a good standard.
nomates
nomates
World Class
World Class (5.7K reputation)World Class (5.7K reputation)World Class (5.7K reputation)World Class (5.7K reputation)World Class (5.7K reputation)World Class (5.7K reputation)World Class (5.7K reputation)World Class (5.7K reputation)World Class (5.7K reputation)World Class (5.7K reputation)World Class (5.7K reputation)

Group: Banned Members
Posts: 5.5K, Visits: 0
P&R would kill teams like WSW and Roar and the likes of CCM and Nixs. We need to aim for a 16 team league then start dreaming about P&R with park football.

Wellington Phoenix FC

P&R will fix it 2.0
P&R will fix it 2.0
Pro
Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 4.8K, Visits: 0
nomates - 3 Dec 2018 9:40 PM
P&R would kill teams like WSW and Roar and the likes of CCM and Nixs.

What's the downside?


Closed HAL is failing with 10 teams
Closed HAL failed with 11
FFA forced to try a 12 team Closed HAL thatll just create 2 more mid table also-rans
and still this weird 16-team panacea gets trotted out. 
Theres a sticky for this nonsense
https://forum.insidesport.com.au/1617388/The-Aleague-Expansion-Thread

WSF
WSF
Pro
Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)Pro (4.9K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 4.6K, Visits: 0
Nix are already dead going by their crowd figures. 
GO


Select a Forum....























Inside Sport


Search